Variation in measured values of photosynthetic quantum yield in ecophysiological studies

Eric L. Singsaas, Donald R. Ort, Evan H. DeLucia

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Photosynthetic efficiency is often quantified as the light-limited, maximum quantum yield in ecophysiological studies. Four published comparative studies report that photosynthetic efficiency varies little among plant species of widely diverse origins, and that quantum yields were near the maximum theoretically attainable value. However, many other published studies contradict this conclusion, reporting quantum yields as low as 30% of those found in the comparative studies. These studies have created the impression that certain plants, particularly wild plants growing outdoors, may have intrinsically low photosynthetic efficiencies. To investigate the validity of these differing interpretations, we compiled quantum yield data from a survey of 30 published studies and compared those with data from the two most comprehensive comparative quantum yield studies. We also included quantum yield observations that we made on ten species. While our data confirm the results of the comparative studies indicating that maximum quantum yield is high and invariant, the literature survey data showed a wide range of quantum yield values. To investigate whether low quantum yield values could be caused by data collection and analysis techniques, we analyzed photosynthetic light-response data. Substantial underestimation of quantum yield could result from including in the calculation data extending beyond the linear region of the photosynthetic light response. In some cases quantum yield measurements can be influenced by changing levels of intercellular CO2 during measurements. We conclude that many quantum yield values reported in the literature are affected by one or more of these errors, and the intrinsic efficiency of photosynthesis is mostly invariant among C3 plants. This emphasizes the importance of the measurement and data analysis protocols in obtaining accurate and reliable quantum yield data.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)15-23
Number of pages9
JournalOecologia
Volume128
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 20 2001

Fingerprint

comparative study
data analysis
C3 plant
C3 plants
wild plants
photosynthesis
methodology
plant species
analysis
protocol
calculation
wild plant

Keywords

  • COassimilation
  • O evolution
  • Photosynthesis
  • Quantum yield
  • Sun/shade

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Variation in measured values of photosynthetic quantum yield in ecophysiological studies. / Singsaas, Eric L.; Ort, Donald R.; DeLucia, Evan H.

In: Oecologia, Vol. 128, No. 1, 20.07.2001, p. 15-23.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{5b12a9cefadd4fbb97d2dedd30adfd2d,
title = "Variation in measured values of photosynthetic quantum yield in ecophysiological studies",
abstract = "Photosynthetic efficiency is often quantified as the light-limited, maximum quantum yield in ecophysiological studies. Four published comparative studies report that photosynthetic efficiency varies little among plant species of widely diverse origins, and that quantum yields were near the maximum theoretically attainable value. However, many other published studies contradict this conclusion, reporting quantum yields as low as 30{\%} of those found in the comparative studies. These studies have created the impression that certain plants, particularly wild plants growing outdoors, may have intrinsically low photosynthetic efficiencies. To investigate the validity of these differing interpretations, we compiled quantum yield data from a survey of 30 published studies and compared those with data from the two most comprehensive comparative quantum yield studies. We also included quantum yield observations that we made on ten species. While our data confirm the results of the comparative studies indicating that maximum quantum yield is high and invariant, the literature survey data showed a wide range of quantum yield values. To investigate whether low quantum yield values could be caused by data collection and analysis techniques, we analyzed photosynthetic light-response data. Substantial underestimation of quantum yield could result from including in the calculation data extending beyond the linear region of the photosynthetic light response. In some cases quantum yield measurements can be influenced by changing levels of intercellular CO2 during measurements. We conclude that many quantum yield values reported in the literature are affected by one or more of these errors, and the intrinsic efficiency of photosynthesis is mostly invariant among C3 plants. This emphasizes the importance of the measurement and data analysis protocols in obtaining accurate and reliable quantum yield data.",
keywords = "COassimilation, O evolution, Photosynthesis, Quantum yield, Sun/shade",
author = "Singsaas, {Eric L.} and Ort, {Donald R.} and DeLucia, {Evan H.}",
year = "2001",
month = "7",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1007/s004420000624",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "128",
pages = "15--23",
journal = "Oecologia",
issn = "0029-8519",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Variation in measured values of photosynthetic quantum yield in ecophysiological studies

AU - Singsaas, Eric L.

AU - Ort, Donald R.

AU - DeLucia, Evan H.

PY - 2001/7/20

Y1 - 2001/7/20

N2 - Photosynthetic efficiency is often quantified as the light-limited, maximum quantum yield in ecophysiological studies. Four published comparative studies report that photosynthetic efficiency varies little among plant species of widely diverse origins, and that quantum yields were near the maximum theoretically attainable value. However, many other published studies contradict this conclusion, reporting quantum yields as low as 30% of those found in the comparative studies. These studies have created the impression that certain plants, particularly wild plants growing outdoors, may have intrinsically low photosynthetic efficiencies. To investigate the validity of these differing interpretations, we compiled quantum yield data from a survey of 30 published studies and compared those with data from the two most comprehensive comparative quantum yield studies. We also included quantum yield observations that we made on ten species. While our data confirm the results of the comparative studies indicating that maximum quantum yield is high and invariant, the literature survey data showed a wide range of quantum yield values. To investigate whether low quantum yield values could be caused by data collection and analysis techniques, we analyzed photosynthetic light-response data. Substantial underestimation of quantum yield could result from including in the calculation data extending beyond the linear region of the photosynthetic light response. In some cases quantum yield measurements can be influenced by changing levels of intercellular CO2 during measurements. We conclude that many quantum yield values reported in the literature are affected by one or more of these errors, and the intrinsic efficiency of photosynthesis is mostly invariant among C3 plants. This emphasizes the importance of the measurement and data analysis protocols in obtaining accurate and reliable quantum yield data.

AB - Photosynthetic efficiency is often quantified as the light-limited, maximum quantum yield in ecophysiological studies. Four published comparative studies report that photosynthetic efficiency varies little among plant species of widely diverse origins, and that quantum yields were near the maximum theoretically attainable value. However, many other published studies contradict this conclusion, reporting quantum yields as low as 30% of those found in the comparative studies. These studies have created the impression that certain plants, particularly wild plants growing outdoors, may have intrinsically low photosynthetic efficiencies. To investigate the validity of these differing interpretations, we compiled quantum yield data from a survey of 30 published studies and compared those with data from the two most comprehensive comparative quantum yield studies. We also included quantum yield observations that we made on ten species. While our data confirm the results of the comparative studies indicating that maximum quantum yield is high and invariant, the literature survey data showed a wide range of quantum yield values. To investigate whether low quantum yield values could be caused by data collection and analysis techniques, we analyzed photosynthetic light-response data. Substantial underestimation of quantum yield could result from including in the calculation data extending beyond the linear region of the photosynthetic light response. In some cases quantum yield measurements can be influenced by changing levels of intercellular CO2 during measurements. We conclude that many quantum yield values reported in the literature are affected by one or more of these errors, and the intrinsic efficiency of photosynthesis is mostly invariant among C3 plants. This emphasizes the importance of the measurement and data analysis protocols in obtaining accurate and reliable quantum yield data.

KW - COassimilation

KW - O evolution

KW - Photosynthesis

KW - Quantum yield

KW - Sun/shade

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034941361&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034941361&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s004420000624

DO - 10.1007/s004420000624

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0034941361

VL - 128

SP - 15

EP - 23

JO - Oecologia

JF - Oecologia

SN - 0029-8519

IS - 1

ER -