The H-cluster of [FeFe] Hydrogenases: Its Enzymatic Synthesis and Parallel Inorganic Semisynthesis

Conspectus Nature’s prototypical hydrogen-forming catalysts─hydrogenases─have attracted much attention because they catalyze hydrogen evolution at near zero overpotential and ambient conditions. Beyond any possible applications in the energy sphere, the hydrogenases feature complicated active sites, which implies novel biosynthetic pathways. In terms of the variety of cofactors, the [FeFe]-hydrogenase is among the most complex. For more than a decade, we have worked on the biosynthesis of the active site of [FeFe] hydrogenases. This site, the H-cluster, is a six-iron ensemble consisting of a [4Fe-4S]_H cluster linked to a [2Fe]_H cluster that is coordinated to CO, cyanide, and a unique organic azadithiolate ligand. Many years ago, three enzymes, namely, HydG, HydE, and HydF, were shown to be required for the biosynthesis and the in vitro maturation of [FeFe] hydrogenases. The structures of the maturases were determined crystallographically, but still little progress was made on the biosynthetic pathway. As described in this Account, the elucidation of the biosynthetic pathway began in earnest with the identification of a molecular iron-cysteinate complex produced within HydG. In this Account, we present our most recent progress toward the molecular mechanism of [2Fe]_H biosynthesis using a collaborative approach involving cell-free biosynthesis, isotope and element-sensitive spectroscopies, as well as inorganic synthesis of purported biosynthetic intermediates. Our study starts from the radical SAM enzyme HydG that lyses tyrosine into CO and cyanide and forms an Fe(CO)₂(CN)-containing species. Crystallographic identification of a unique auxiliary 5Fe-4S cluster in HydG leads to a proposed catalytic cycle in which a free cysteine-chelated “dangler” Fe serves as the platform for the stepwise formation of a [4Fe-4S][Fe(CO)(CN)(cysteinate)] intermediate, which releases the [Fe(CO)₂(CN)(cysteinate)] product, Complex B. Since Complex B is unstable, we applied synthetic organometallic chemistry to make an analogue, syn-B, and showed that it fully replaces HydG in the in vitro maturation of the H-cluster. Syn-B serves as the substrate for the next radical SAM enzyme HydE, where the low-spin Fe(II) center is activated by 5′-dAdo^• to form an adenosylated Fe(I) intermediate. We propose that this Fe(I) species strips the carbon backbone and dimerizes in HydE to form a [Fe₂(SH)₂(CO)₄(CN)₂]^2- product. This mechanistic scenario is supported by the use of a synthetic version of this dimer complex, syn-dimer, which allows for the formation of active hydrogenase with only the HydF maturase. Further application of this semisynthesis strategy shows that an [Fe₂(SCH₂NH₂)₂(CO)₄(CN)₂]^2- complex can activate the apo hydrogenase, marking it as the last biosynthetic intermediate en route to the H-cluster. This combined enzymatic and semisynthetic approach greatly accelerates our understanding of H-cluster biosynthesis. We anticipate additional mechanistic details regarding H-cluster biosynthesis to be gleaned, and this methodology may be further applied in the study of other complex metallocofactors.