Success and failure: How systemic racism trumped the Brown v. Board of Education decision

Joe R. Feagin, Bernice McNair Barnett

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Despite the enactment of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868, legal segregation nevertheless remained pervasive throughout the United States in the following nine decades due to various state statutes and federal and state court decisions. Nowhere was the existence of legal segregation more prevalent than in school systems throughout the United States. Segregated schools were common because of the U.S. Supreme Court's "separate but equal" doctrine set forth in Plessy v. Ferguson Finally, in 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision, concluded that "in the field of public education the doctrine of 'separate but equal' has no place" because "separate educational facilities are inherently unequal." With that language, the Supreme Court effectively rejected the legality of school segregation. The implications of the Court's Brown decision extended beyond the educational system. Professors Feagin and Barnett note that the Court's Brown decision marked the first time it recognized African Americans as first-class citizens. Additionally, they state that the decision had an important psychological impact on African Americans and provided moral encouragement to people active in the civil rights movement. Further, Brown supplied the legal precedent necessary to dismantle state-created segregation in other areas. Finally, Professors Feagin and Barnett remark that Brown remains a "beacon of liberty" for people throughout the United States and the world seeking to end discrimination in myriad other areas. Professors Feagin and Barnett argue, however, that despite the positive effects in education and other areas resulting from the Court's Brown decision, the decision has by no means been successful in dismantling institutionalized racism in American education. They note that although schools may be officially desegregated, they never-theless remain effectively segregated due to the following: discrimination in schools by administrators, teachers, and students; racial bias in school curriculum; the separation of students into different ability tracks reflecting racial, class, and gender stratification; and the use of standardized testing that contains significant racial and class bias. While emphasizing linkages to class stratification and income-based housing segregation, Professors Feagin and Barnett argue that the failures in desegregation since Brown are primarily the result of systemic racism, which they define as the "racialized exploitation and subordination of Americans of color by white Americans" that "encompasses the racial stereotyping, prejudices, and emotions of whites, as well as the discriminatory practices and racialized institutions generated for the long-term domination of African Americans and other people of color." They note that a clear indication of systemic racism has been the unwillingness by both federal courts and presidential administrations to ensure that Brown's ideals are fully implemented. The authors also argue that recent presidential administrations have failed to develop educational policies that remove the burdens placed on many children by an ineffective, and still segregated, educational system.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1099-1130
Number of pages32
JournalUniversity of Illinois Law Review
Volume2004
Issue number5
StatePublished - 2004

Fingerprint

segregation
racism
court decision
university teacher
Supreme Court
education
school
educational system
doctrine
discrimination
people of color
civil rights movement
dismantling
legality
public education
trend
school system
educational policy
domination
prejudice

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Law

Cite this

Success and failure : How systemic racism trumped the Brown v. Board of Education decision. / Feagin, Joe R.; Barnett, Bernice McNair.

In: University of Illinois Law Review, Vol. 2004, No. 5, 2004, p. 1099-1130.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a974bb470a1a4cd9b0b272b25d903416,
title = "Success and failure: How systemic racism trumped the Brown v. Board of Education decision",
abstract = "Despite the enactment of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868, legal segregation nevertheless remained pervasive throughout the United States in the following nine decades due to various state statutes and federal and state court decisions. Nowhere was the existence of legal segregation more prevalent than in school systems throughout the United States. Segregated schools were common because of the U.S. Supreme Court's {"}separate but equal{"} doctrine set forth in Plessy v. Ferguson Finally, in 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision, concluded that {"}in the field of public education the doctrine of 'separate but equal' has no place{"} because {"}separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.{"} With that language, the Supreme Court effectively rejected the legality of school segregation. The implications of the Court's Brown decision extended beyond the educational system. Professors Feagin and Barnett note that the Court's Brown decision marked the first time it recognized African Americans as first-class citizens. Additionally, they state that the decision had an important psychological impact on African Americans and provided moral encouragement to people active in the civil rights movement. Further, Brown supplied the legal precedent necessary to dismantle state-created segregation in other areas. Finally, Professors Feagin and Barnett remark that Brown remains a {"}beacon of liberty{"} for people throughout the United States and the world seeking to end discrimination in myriad other areas. Professors Feagin and Barnett argue, however, that despite the positive effects in education and other areas resulting from the Court's Brown decision, the decision has by no means been successful in dismantling institutionalized racism in American education. They note that although schools may be officially desegregated, they never-theless remain effectively segregated due to the following: discrimination in schools by administrators, teachers, and students; racial bias in school curriculum; the separation of students into different ability tracks reflecting racial, class, and gender stratification; and the use of standardized testing that contains significant racial and class bias. While emphasizing linkages to class stratification and income-based housing segregation, Professors Feagin and Barnett argue that the failures in desegregation since Brown are primarily the result of systemic racism, which they define as the {"}racialized exploitation and subordination of Americans of color by white Americans{"} that {"}encompasses the racial stereotyping, prejudices, and emotions of whites, as well as the discriminatory practices and racialized institutions generated for the long-term domination of African Americans and other people of color.{"} They note that a clear indication of systemic racism has been the unwillingness by both federal courts and presidential administrations to ensure that Brown's ideals are fully implemented. The authors also argue that recent presidential administrations have failed to develop educational policies that remove the burdens placed on many children by an ineffective, and still segregated, educational system.",
author = "Feagin, {Joe R.} and Barnett, {Bernice McNair}",
year = "2004",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "2004",
pages = "1099--1130",
journal = "University of Illinois Law Review",
issn = "0276-9948",
publisher = "University of Illinois College of Law",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Success and failure

T2 - How systemic racism trumped the Brown v. Board of Education decision

AU - Feagin, Joe R.

AU - Barnett, Bernice McNair

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - Despite the enactment of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868, legal segregation nevertheless remained pervasive throughout the United States in the following nine decades due to various state statutes and federal and state court decisions. Nowhere was the existence of legal segregation more prevalent than in school systems throughout the United States. Segregated schools were common because of the U.S. Supreme Court's "separate but equal" doctrine set forth in Plessy v. Ferguson Finally, in 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision, concluded that "in the field of public education the doctrine of 'separate but equal' has no place" because "separate educational facilities are inherently unequal." With that language, the Supreme Court effectively rejected the legality of school segregation. The implications of the Court's Brown decision extended beyond the educational system. Professors Feagin and Barnett note that the Court's Brown decision marked the first time it recognized African Americans as first-class citizens. Additionally, they state that the decision had an important psychological impact on African Americans and provided moral encouragement to people active in the civil rights movement. Further, Brown supplied the legal precedent necessary to dismantle state-created segregation in other areas. Finally, Professors Feagin and Barnett remark that Brown remains a "beacon of liberty" for people throughout the United States and the world seeking to end discrimination in myriad other areas. Professors Feagin and Barnett argue, however, that despite the positive effects in education and other areas resulting from the Court's Brown decision, the decision has by no means been successful in dismantling institutionalized racism in American education. They note that although schools may be officially desegregated, they never-theless remain effectively segregated due to the following: discrimination in schools by administrators, teachers, and students; racial bias in school curriculum; the separation of students into different ability tracks reflecting racial, class, and gender stratification; and the use of standardized testing that contains significant racial and class bias. While emphasizing linkages to class stratification and income-based housing segregation, Professors Feagin and Barnett argue that the failures in desegregation since Brown are primarily the result of systemic racism, which they define as the "racialized exploitation and subordination of Americans of color by white Americans" that "encompasses the racial stereotyping, prejudices, and emotions of whites, as well as the discriminatory practices and racialized institutions generated for the long-term domination of African Americans and other people of color." They note that a clear indication of systemic racism has been the unwillingness by both federal courts and presidential administrations to ensure that Brown's ideals are fully implemented. The authors also argue that recent presidential administrations have failed to develop educational policies that remove the burdens placed on many children by an ineffective, and still segregated, educational system.

AB - Despite the enactment of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868, legal segregation nevertheless remained pervasive throughout the United States in the following nine decades due to various state statutes and federal and state court decisions. Nowhere was the existence of legal segregation more prevalent than in school systems throughout the United States. Segregated schools were common because of the U.S. Supreme Court's "separate but equal" doctrine set forth in Plessy v. Ferguson Finally, in 1954, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision, concluded that "in the field of public education the doctrine of 'separate but equal' has no place" because "separate educational facilities are inherently unequal." With that language, the Supreme Court effectively rejected the legality of school segregation. The implications of the Court's Brown decision extended beyond the educational system. Professors Feagin and Barnett note that the Court's Brown decision marked the first time it recognized African Americans as first-class citizens. Additionally, they state that the decision had an important psychological impact on African Americans and provided moral encouragement to people active in the civil rights movement. Further, Brown supplied the legal precedent necessary to dismantle state-created segregation in other areas. Finally, Professors Feagin and Barnett remark that Brown remains a "beacon of liberty" for people throughout the United States and the world seeking to end discrimination in myriad other areas. Professors Feagin and Barnett argue, however, that despite the positive effects in education and other areas resulting from the Court's Brown decision, the decision has by no means been successful in dismantling institutionalized racism in American education. They note that although schools may be officially desegregated, they never-theless remain effectively segregated due to the following: discrimination in schools by administrators, teachers, and students; racial bias in school curriculum; the separation of students into different ability tracks reflecting racial, class, and gender stratification; and the use of standardized testing that contains significant racial and class bias. While emphasizing linkages to class stratification and income-based housing segregation, Professors Feagin and Barnett argue that the failures in desegregation since Brown are primarily the result of systemic racism, which they define as the "racialized exploitation and subordination of Americans of color by white Americans" that "encompasses the racial stereotyping, prejudices, and emotions of whites, as well as the discriminatory practices and racialized institutions generated for the long-term domination of African Americans and other people of color." They note that a clear indication of systemic racism has been the unwillingness by both federal courts and presidential administrations to ensure that Brown's ideals are fully implemented. The authors also argue that recent presidential administrations have failed to develop educational policies that remove the burdens placed on many children by an ineffective, and still segregated, educational system.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=17544363353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=17544363353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:17544363353

VL - 2004

SP - 1099

EP - 1130

JO - University of Illinois Law Review

JF - University of Illinois Law Review

SN - 0276-9948

IS - 5

ER -