Sediment mobility and bed armoring in the St Clair River: Insights from hydrodynamic modeling

Xiaofeng Liu, Gary Parker, Jonathan A. Czuba, Kevin Oberg, Jose M. Mier, James Leonard Best, Daniel R. Parsons, Peter Ashmore, Bommanna G. Krishnappan, Marcelo Horacio Garcia

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The lake levels in Lake Michigan-Huron have recently fallen to near historical lows, as has the elevation difference between Lake Michigan-Huron compared to Lake Erie. This decline in lake levels has the potential to cause detrimental impacts on the lake ecosystems, together with social and economic impacts on communities in the entire Great Lakes region. Results from past work suggest that morphological changes in the St Clair River, which is the only natural outlet for Lake Michigan-Huron, could be an appreciable factor in the recent trends of lake level decline. A key research question is whether bed erosion within the river has caused an increase in water conveyance, therefore, contributed to the falling lake level. In this paper, a numerical modeling approach with field data is used to investigate the possibility of sediment movement in the St Clair River and assess the likelihood of morphological change under the current flow regime. A two-dimensional numerical model was used to study flow structure, bed shear stress, and sediment mobility/armoring over a range of flow discharges. Boundary conditions for the numerical model were provided by detailed field measurements that included high-resolution bathymetry and three-dimensional flow velocities. The results indicate that, without considering other effects, under the current range of flow conditions, the shear stresses produced by the river flow are too low to transport most of the coarse bed sediment within the reach and are too low to cause substantial bed erosion or bed scour. However, the detailed maps of the bed show mobile bedforms in the upper St Clair River that are indicative of sediment transport. Relatively high shear stresses near a constriction at the upstream end of the river and at channel bends could cause local scour and deposition. Ship-induced propeller wake erosion also is a likely cause of sediment movement in the entire reach. Other factors that may promote sediment movement, such as ice cover and dredging in the lower river, require further investigation.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)957-970
Number of pages14
JournalEarth Surface Processes and Landforms
Volume37
Issue number9
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2012

Fingerprint

hydrodynamics
river
lake level
sediment
lake
modeling
shear stress
erosion
scour
cause
three-dimensional flow
lake ecosystem
bottom stress
social impact
flow structure
bedform
dredging
ice cover
economic impact
river flow

Keywords

  • Armoring
  • Bathymetry
  • Field measurement
  • Gravel bed
  • Morphology
  • Numerical model
  • Sediment transport
  • St Clair River
  • Till erosion

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Earth-Surface Processes
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Sediment mobility and bed armoring in the St Clair River : Insights from hydrodynamic modeling. / Liu, Xiaofeng; Parker, Gary; Czuba, Jonathan A.; Oberg, Kevin; Mier, Jose M.; Best, James Leonard; Parsons, Daniel R.; Ashmore, Peter; Krishnappan, Bommanna G.; Garcia, Marcelo Horacio.

In: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, Vol. 37, No. 9, 01.07.2012, p. 957-970.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Liu, Xiaofeng ; Parker, Gary ; Czuba, Jonathan A. ; Oberg, Kevin ; Mier, Jose M. ; Best, James Leonard ; Parsons, Daniel R. ; Ashmore, Peter ; Krishnappan, Bommanna G. ; Garcia, Marcelo Horacio. / Sediment mobility and bed armoring in the St Clair River : Insights from hydrodynamic modeling. In: Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. 2012 ; Vol. 37, No. 9. pp. 957-970.
@article{57099b2f0fc44026a96f7fd6d936b6ad,
title = "Sediment mobility and bed armoring in the St Clair River: Insights from hydrodynamic modeling",
abstract = "The lake levels in Lake Michigan-Huron have recently fallen to near historical lows, as has the elevation difference between Lake Michigan-Huron compared to Lake Erie. This decline in lake levels has the potential to cause detrimental impacts on the lake ecosystems, together with social and economic impacts on communities in the entire Great Lakes region. Results from past work suggest that morphological changes in the St Clair River, which is the only natural outlet for Lake Michigan-Huron, could be an appreciable factor in the recent trends of lake level decline. A key research question is whether bed erosion within the river has caused an increase in water conveyance, therefore, contributed to the falling lake level. In this paper, a numerical modeling approach with field data is used to investigate the possibility of sediment movement in the St Clair River and assess the likelihood of morphological change under the current flow regime. A two-dimensional numerical model was used to study flow structure, bed shear stress, and sediment mobility/armoring over a range of flow discharges. Boundary conditions for the numerical model were provided by detailed field measurements that included high-resolution bathymetry and three-dimensional flow velocities. The results indicate that, without considering other effects, under the current range of flow conditions, the shear stresses produced by the river flow are too low to transport most of the coarse bed sediment within the reach and are too low to cause substantial bed erosion or bed scour. However, the detailed maps of the bed show mobile bedforms in the upper St Clair River that are indicative of sediment transport. Relatively high shear stresses near a constriction at the upstream end of the river and at channel bends could cause local scour and deposition. Ship-induced propeller wake erosion also is a likely cause of sediment movement in the entire reach. Other factors that may promote sediment movement, such as ice cover and dredging in the lower river, require further investigation.",
keywords = "Armoring, Bathymetry, Field measurement, Gravel bed, Morphology, Numerical model, Sediment transport, St Clair River, Till erosion",
author = "Xiaofeng Liu and Gary Parker and Czuba, {Jonathan A.} and Kevin Oberg and Mier, {Jose M.} and Best, {James Leonard} and Parsons, {Daniel R.} and Peter Ashmore and Krishnappan, {Bommanna G.} and Garcia, {Marcelo Horacio}",
year = "2012",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/esp.3215",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "37",
pages = "957--970",
journal = "Earth Surface Processes and Landforms",
issn = "0197-9337",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sediment mobility and bed armoring in the St Clair River

T2 - Insights from hydrodynamic modeling

AU - Liu, Xiaofeng

AU - Parker, Gary

AU - Czuba, Jonathan A.

AU - Oberg, Kevin

AU - Mier, Jose M.

AU - Best, James Leonard

AU - Parsons, Daniel R.

AU - Ashmore, Peter

AU - Krishnappan, Bommanna G.

AU - Garcia, Marcelo Horacio

PY - 2012/7/1

Y1 - 2012/7/1

N2 - The lake levels in Lake Michigan-Huron have recently fallen to near historical lows, as has the elevation difference between Lake Michigan-Huron compared to Lake Erie. This decline in lake levels has the potential to cause detrimental impacts on the lake ecosystems, together with social and economic impacts on communities in the entire Great Lakes region. Results from past work suggest that morphological changes in the St Clair River, which is the only natural outlet for Lake Michigan-Huron, could be an appreciable factor in the recent trends of lake level decline. A key research question is whether bed erosion within the river has caused an increase in water conveyance, therefore, contributed to the falling lake level. In this paper, a numerical modeling approach with field data is used to investigate the possibility of sediment movement in the St Clair River and assess the likelihood of morphological change under the current flow regime. A two-dimensional numerical model was used to study flow structure, bed shear stress, and sediment mobility/armoring over a range of flow discharges. Boundary conditions for the numerical model were provided by detailed field measurements that included high-resolution bathymetry and three-dimensional flow velocities. The results indicate that, without considering other effects, under the current range of flow conditions, the shear stresses produced by the river flow are too low to transport most of the coarse bed sediment within the reach and are too low to cause substantial bed erosion or bed scour. However, the detailed maps of the bed show mobile bedforms in the upper St Clair River that are indicative of sediment transport. Relatively high shear stresses near a constriction at the upstream end of the river and at channel bends could cause local scour and deposition. Ship-induced propeller wake erosion also is a likely cause of sediment movement in the entire reach. Other factors that may promote sediment movement, such as ice cover and dredging in the lower river, require further investigation.

AB - The lake levels in Lake Michigan-Huron have recently fallen to near historical lows, as has the elevation difference between Lake Michigan-Huron compared to Lake Erie. This decline in lake levels has the potential to cause detrimental impacts on the lake ecosystems, together with social and economic impacts on communities in the entire Great Lakes region. Results from past work suggest that morphological changes in the St Clair River, which is the only natural outlet for Lake Michigan-Huron, could be an appreciable factor in the recent trends of lake level decline. A key research question is whether bed erosion within the river has caused an increase in water conveyance, therefore, contributed to the falling lake level. In this paper, a numerical modeling approach with field data is used to investigate the possibility of sediment movement in the St Clair River and assess the likelihood of morphological change under the current flow regime. A two-dimensional numerical model was used to study flow structure, bed shear stress, and sediment mobility/armoring over a range of flow discharges. Boundary conditions for the numerical model were provided by detailed field measurements that included high-resolution bathymetry and three-dimensional flow velocities. The results indicate that, without considering other effects, under the current range of flow conditions, the shear stresses produced by the river flow are too low to transport most of the coarse bed sediment within the reach and are too low to cause substantial bed erosion or bed scour. However, the detailed maps of the bed show mobile bedforms in the upper St Clair River that are indicative of sediment transport. Relatively high shear stresses near a constriction at the upstream end of the river and at channel bends could cause local scour and deposition. Ship-induced propeller wake erosion also is a likely cause of sediment movement in the entire reach. Other factors that may promote sediment movement, such as ice cover and dredging in the lower river, require further investigation.

KW - Armoring

KW - Bathymetry

KW - Field measurement

KW - Gravel bed

KW - Morphology

KW - Numerical model

KW - Sediment transport

KW - St Clair River

KW - Till erosion

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84863323237&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84863323237&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/esp.3215

DO - 10.1002/esp.3215

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84863323237

VL - 37

SP - 957

EP - 970

JO - Earth Surface Processes and Landforms

JF - Earth Surface Processes and Landforms

SN - 0197-9337

IS - 9

ER -