Research without Archives? The Making and Remaking of Area Studies Knowledge of the Middle East in a Time of Chronic War

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The Middle East is home to ancient historical documents of great value to archivists and historians. Systemic violence, warfare, and political instability in the region since the invasion of Iraq in 2003 have taken a terrible toll on documents and archives as well as human life. The destruction of libraries that house primary source materials affects the creation of knowledge in Middle Eastern studies in important ways that remain to be understood. In this article, I review the extent of the damage to libraries and archives in the region since the US invasion of Iraq in 2003 and then ask: What happens to Middle Eastern studies when archives are destroyed and researchers must change their topics and methods of research? Can we create knowledge about a region when its archival resources and human informants are so endangered? If access to archival materials is essential to the very essence of Middle Eastern studies, then what is happening to that field and why should that matter to archivists? I recount anecdotal evidence of researchers changing the topics and themes of their research in response to a situation of limited access to archives and to the region, and then present outcomes of a survey I designed to understand more systematically how these problems are affecting the shape of research and knowledge about the Middle East. Finally, I present an aspirational call to the cultural heritage preservation community – researchers, archivists, and librarians – to digitize archival resources in the Middle East.
Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)68-95
JournalArchivaria
Volume85
StatePublished - May 7 2018

Fingerprint

Middle East
archivist
invasion
Iraq
warfare
cultural heritage
resources
historian
librarian
damages
violence
time
present
community
evidence
Values

Keywords

  • fieldwork
  • Archives
  • unrest
  • knowledge
  • Middle East
  • perservation
  • interdisciplinary
  • open repositories
  • sharing data

Cite this

@article{069b571c410a4c69a8e0ecae0734f2e4,
title = "Research without Archives?: The Making and Remaking of Area Studies Knowledge of the Middle East in a Time of Chronic War",
abstract = "The Middle East is home to ancient historical documents of great value to archivists and historians. Systemic violence, warfare, and political instability in the region since the invasion of Iraq in 2003 have taken a terrible toll on documents and archives as well as human life. The destruction of libraries that house primary source materials affects the creation of knowledge in Middle Eastern studies in important ways that remain to be understood. In this article, I review the extent of the damage to libraries and archives in the region since the US invasion of Iraq in 2003 and then ask: What happens to Middle Eastern studies when archives are destroyed and researchers must change their topics and methods of research? Can we create knowledge about a region when its archival resources and human informants are so endangered? If access to archival materials is essential to the very essence of Middle Eastern studies, then what is happening to that field and why should that matter to archivists? I recount anecdotal evidence of researchers changing the topics and themes of their research in response to a situation of limited access to archives and to the region, and then present outcomes of a survey I designed to understand more systematically how these problems are affecting the shape of research and knowledge about the Middle East. Finally, I present an aspirational call to the cultural heritage preservation community – researchers, archivists, and librarians – to digitize archival resources in the Middle East.",
keywords = "fieldwork, Archives, unrest, knowledge, Middle East, perservation, interdisciplinary, open repositories, sharing data",
author = "{Hussein Moustafa}, Laila",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "7",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "85",
pages = "68--95",
journal = "Archivaria",
issn = "0318-6954",
publisher = "Association of Canadian Archivists",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Research without Archives?

T2 - The Making and Remaking of Area Studies Knowledge of the Middle East in a Time of Chronic War

AU - Hussein Moustafa, Laila

PY - 2018/5/7

Y1 - 2018/5/7

N2 - The Middle East is home to ancient historical documents of great value to archivists and historians. Systemic violence, warfare, and political instability in the region since the invasion of Iraq in 2003 have taken a terrible toll on documents and archives as well as human life. The destruction of libraries that house primary source materials affects the creation of knowledge in Middle Eastern studies in important ways that remain to be understood. In this article, I review the extent of the damage to libraries and archives in the region since the US invasion of Iraq in 2003 and then ask: What happens to Middle Eastern studies when archives are destroyed and researchers must change their topics and methods of research? Can we create knowledge about a region when its archival resources and human informants are so endangered? If access to archival materials is essential to the very essence of Middle Eastern studies, then what is happening to that field and why should that matter to archivists? I recount anecdotal evidence of researchers changing the topics and themes of their research in response to a situation of limited access to archives and to the region, and then present outcomes of a survey I designed to understand more systematically how these problems are affecting the shape of research and knowledge about the Middle East. Finally, I present an aspirational call to the cultural heritage preservation community – researchers, archivists, and librarians – to digitize archival resources in the Middle East.

AB - The Middle East is home to ancient historical documents of great value to archivists and historians. Systemic violence, warfare, and political instability in the region since the invasion of Iraq in 2003 have taken a terrible toll on documents and archives as well as human life. The destruction of libraries that house primary source materials affects the creation of knowledge in Middle Eastern studies in important ways that remain to be understood. In this article, I review the extent of the damage to libraries and archives in the region since the US invasion of Iraq in 2003 and then ask: What happens to Middle Eastern studies when archives are destroyed and researchers must change their topics and methods of research? Can we create knowledge about a region when its archival resources and human informants are so endangered? If access to archival materials is essential to the very essence of Middle Eastern studies, then what is happening to that field and why should that matter to archivists? I recount anecdotal evidence of researchers changing the topics and themes of their research in response to a situation of limited access to archives and to the region, and then present outcomes of a survey I designed to understand more systematically how these problems are affecting the shape of research and knowledge about the Middle East. Finally, I present an aspirational call to the cultural heritage preservation community – researchers, archivists, and librarians – to digitize archival resources in the Middle East.

KW - fieldwork

KW - Archives

KW - unrest

KW - knowledge

KW - Middle East

KW - perservation

KW - interdisciplinary

KW - open repositories

KW - sharing data

M3 - Article

VL - 85

SP - 68

EP - 95

JO - Archivaria

JF - Archivaria

SN - 0318-6954

ER -