Predicting Search Performance in Heterogeneous Scenes

Quantifying the Impact of Homogeneity Effects in Efficient Search

Alejandro Lleras, Zhiyuan Wang, Anna Madison, Simona Buetti

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Recently, Wang, Buetti and Lleras (2017) developed an equation to predict search performance in heterogeneous visual search scenes (i.e., multiple types of non-target objects simultaneously present) based on parameters observed when participants perform search in homogeneous scenes (i.e., when all non-target objects are identical to one another). The equation was based on a computational model where every item in the display is processed with unlimited capacity and independently of one another, with the goal of determining whether the item is likely to be a target or not. The model was tested in two experiments using real-world objects. Here, we extend those findings by testing the predictive power of the equation to simpler objects. Further, we compare the model’s performance under two stimulus arrangements: spatially-intermixed (items randomly placed around the scene) and spatially-segregated displays (identical items presented near each other). This comparison allowed us to isolate and quantify the facilitatory effect of processing displays that contain identical items (homogeneity facilitation), a factor that improves performance in visual search above-and-beyond target-distractor dissimilarity. The results suggest that homogeneity facilitation effects in search arise from local item-to-item interaction (rather than by rejecting items as “groups”) and that the strength of those interactions might be determined by stimulus complexity (with simpler stimuli producing stronger interactions and thus, stronger homogeneity facilitation effects).
Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2
JournalCollabra: Psychology
Volume5
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 8 2019

Keywords

  • visual search
  • heterogeneity effect
  • homogeneity facilitation
  • local interaction
  • independent processing

Cite this

Predicting Search Performance in Heterogeneous Scenes : Quantifying the Impact of Homogeneity Effects in Efficient Search. / Lleras, Alejandro; Wang, Zhiyuan; Madison, Anna; Buetti, Simona.

In: Collabra: Psychology, Vol. 5, No. 1, 08.01.2019, p. 2.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{314e417ffc4b45d2bb10bff642e02d0f,
title = "Predicting Search Performance in Heterogeneous Scenes: Quantifying the Impact of Homogeneity Effects in Efficient Search",
abstract = "Recently, Wang, Buetti and Lleras (2017) developed an equation to predict search performance in heterogeneous visual search scenes (i.e., multiple types of non-target objects simultaneously present) based on parameters observed when participants perform search in homogeneous scenes (i.e., when all non-target objects are identical to one another). The equation was based on a computational model where every item in the display is processed with unlimited capacity and independently of one another, with the goal of determining whether the item is likely to be a target or not. The model was tested in two experiments using real-world objects. Here, we extend those findings by testing the predictive power of the equation to simpler objects. Further, we compare the model’s performance under two stimulus arrangements: spatially-intermixed (items randomly placed around the scene) and spatially-segregated displays (identical items presented near each other). This comparison allowed us to isolate and quantify the facilitatory effect of processing displays that contain identical items (homogeneity facilitation), a factor that improves performance in visual search above-and-beyond target-distractor dissimilarity. The results suggest that homogeneity facilitation effects in search arise from local item-to-item interaction (rather than by rejecting items as “groups”) and that the strength of those interactions might be determined by stimulus complexity (with simpler stimuli producing stronger interactions and thus, stronger homogeneity facilitation effects).",
keywords = "visual search, heterogeneity effect, homogeneity facilitation, local interaction, independent processing",
author = "Alejandro Lleras and Zhiyuan Wang and Anna Madison and Simona Buetti",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "8",
doi = "10.1525/collabra.151",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "5",
pages = "2",
journal = "Collabra: Psychology",
issn = "2474-7394",
publisher = "University of California Press",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Predicting Search Performance in Heterogeneous Scenes

T2 - Quantifying the Impact of Homogeneity Effects in Efficient Search

AU - Lleras, Alejandro

AU - Wang, Zhiyuan

AU - Madison, Anna

AU - Buetti, Simona

PY - 2019/1/8

Y1 - 2019/1/8

N2 - Recently, Wang, Buetti and Lleras (2017) developed an equation to predict search performance in heterogeneous visual search scenes (i.e., multiple types of non-target objects simultaneously present) based on parameters observed when participants perform search in homogeneous scenes (i.e., when all non-target objects are identical to one another). The equation was based on a computational model where every item in the display is processed with unlimited capacity and independently of one another, with the goal of determining whether the item is likely to be a target or not. The model was tested in two experiments using real-world objects. Here, we extend those findings by testing the predictive power of the equation to simpler objects. Further, we compare the model’s performance under two stimulus arrangements: spatially-intermixed (items randomly placed around the scene) and spatially-segregated displays (identical items presented near each other). This comparison allowed us to isolate and quantify the facilitatory effect of processing displays that contain identical items (homogeneity facilitation), a factor that improves performance in visual search above-and-beyond target-distractor dissimilarity. The results suggest that homogeneity facilitation effects in search arise from local item-to-item interaction (rather than by rejecting items as “groups”) and that the strength of those interactions might be determined by stimulus complexity (with simpler stimuli producing stronger interactions and thus, stronger homogeneity facilitation effects).

AB - Recently, Wang, Buetti and Lleras (2017) developed an equation to predict search performance in heterogeneous visual search scenes (i.e., multiple types of non-target objects simultaneously present) based on parameters observed when participants perform search in homogeneous scenes (i.e., when all non-target objects are identical to one another). The equation was based on a computational model where every item in the display is processed with unlimited capacity and independently of one another, with the goal of determining whether the item is likely to be a target or not. The model was tested in two experiments using real-world objects. Here, we extend those findings by testing the predictive power of the equation to simpler objects. Further, we compare the model’s performance under two stimulus arrangements: spatially-intermixed (items randomly placed around the scene) and spatially-segregated displays (identical items presented near each other). This comparison allowed us to isolate and quantify the facilitatory effect of processing displays that contain identical items (homogeneity facilitation), a factor that improves performance in visual search above-and-beyond target-distractor dissimilarity. The results suggest that homogeneity facilitation effects in search arise from local item-to-item interaction (rather than by rejecting items as “groups”) and that the strength of those interactions might be determined by stimulus complexity (with simpler stimuli producing stronger interactions and thus, stronger homogeneity facilitation effects).

KW - visual search

KW - heterogeneity effect

KW - homogeneity facilitation

KW - local interaction

KW - independent processing

U2 - 10.1525/collabra.151

DO - 10.1525/collabra.151

M3 - Article

VL - 5

SP - 2

JO - Collabra: Psychology

JF - Collabra: Psychology

SN - 2474-7394

IS - 1

ER -