Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics

J. P. Allain, B. Holybee, M. List, A. Kacic, M. Nieto-Perez, M. R. Hendricks

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light at 13.5 nm is a candidate for advanced optical lithography where sub-32 nm features will spawn the next generation of microchips. Plasma-based Sn sources have been used to generate EUV light, but debris contamination and damage limits the life expectancy of plasma-facing collector optics. Although mitigation systems reduce the amount of vapor, thermal and energetic particles still reach mirror surfaces. Three Rh mirror samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic 1 keV Xe+ (12-nA, 120-nA, and 1.2-uA) particles for 36 minutes and three Ru samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic Xe+ (100eV, 500eV, and 1000eV). In-situ measurements of EUV reflectivity and surface composition were correlated with ex-situ morphology investigations. For the Rh mirrors, a combination of 14.7-nA thermal Sn and 1.2-uA energetic Xe+ reduced mirror reflectivity by only 18.7%, as opposed to the 48.5% and 41.7% decreases observed with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, respectively. For the Ru mirrors, the higher 1000eV Xe+ irradiation lowered the reflectivity by 41.6%, while the 500eV and 100eV energy decreased the reflectivity by 44.9% and 51.4% respectively. In-situ low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy (LEISS) monitored the Sn surface fraction. For Rh samples irradiated with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, the fraction was 1 throughout the experiment. The third sample (1.2-uA) initially had a 0.71 surface fraction, which increased towards 1, dropped to 0.48 after 18 minutes, and then continued rising to 0.8 after 36 minutes. The drop suggests a threshold, where perhaps surface structure abruptly changed, that was too high for the other samples to cross. The results imply that at certain fluences, debris bombardment may not be as detrimental to collector mirror EUV reflectivity as at others. For the Ru samples, the Sn surface fraction jumped to 100% for the sample irradiated at 100eV Xe+, to 85% for the 500eV case, and 75% for the 1keV case. The reflectivity was worse with the 100eV sample, with a drop of 51.4%, while the 500eV and 1keV had drops of 44.9% and 41.6%, respectively. Morphology analyses with an atomic force microscope at Purdue University's Radiation Surface and Interface Science Laboratory revealed that the morphology of the mirror surface plays a key role in the reflectivity performance of the Rh and Ru mirrors.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationDamage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III
Volume8077
DOIs
StatePublished - 2011
Externally publishedYes
EventDamage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III - Prague, Czech Republic

Other

OtherDamage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III
CountryCzech Republic
CityPrague
Period4/18/114/20/11

Fingerprint

Mirrors
Mirror
mirrors
Adnexal Diseases
Reflectivity
reflectance
Edema Disease of Swine
Extremes
Hot Temperature
Ultraviolet
Dental Staff
accumulators
Callosities
Ultraviolet Rays
Debris
Surface structure
Optics
Plasma
Damage
Energy

Keywords

  • Atomic force microscopy
  • EUV reflectivity
  • Grazing incidence collector
  • Ruthenium
  • Sn debris
  • Sputtering

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Applied Mathematics
  • Computer Science Applications
  • Electrical and Electronic Engineering
  • Electronic, Optical and Magnetic Materials
  • Condensed Matter Physics

Cite this

Allain, J. P., Holybee, B., List, M., Kacic, A., Nieto-Perez, M., & Hendricks, M. R. (2011). Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics. In Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III (Vol. 8077). [80770I] DOI: 10.1117/12.888369

Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics. / Allain, J. P.; Holybee, B.; List, M.; Kacic, A.; Nieto-Perez, M.; Hendricks, M. R.

Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III. Vol. 8077 2011. 80770I.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Allain, JP, Holybee, B, List, M, Kacic, A, Nieto-Perez, M & Hendricks, MR 2011, Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics. in Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III. vol. 8077, 80770I, Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III, Prague, Czech Republic, 18-20 April. DOI: 10.1117/12.888369
Allain JP, Holybee B, List M, Kacic A, Nieto-Perez M, Hendricks MR. Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics. In Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III. Vol. 8077. 2011. 80770I. Available from, DOI: 10.1117/12.888369

Allain, J. P.; Holybee, B.; List, M.; Kacic, A.; Nieto-Perez, M.; Hendricks, M. R. / Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics.

Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III. Vol. 8077 2011. 80770I.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

@inbook{a50bb20157484bdf8c8b5df634736286,
title = "Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics",
abstract = "Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light at 13.5 nm is a candidate for advanced optical lithography where sub-32 nm features will spawn the next generation of microchips. Plasma-based Sn sources have been used to generate EUV light, but debris contamination and damage limits the life expectancy of plasma-facing collector optics. Although mitigation systems reduce the amount of vapor, thermal and energetic particles still reach mirror surfaces. Three Rh mirror samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic 1 keV Xe+ (12-nA, 120-nA, and 1.2-uA) particles for 36 minutes and three Ru samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic Xe+ (100eV, 500eV, and 1000eV). In-situ measurements of EUV reflectivity and surface composition were correlated with ex-situ morphology investigations. For the Rh mirrors, a combination of 14.7-nA thermal Sn and 1.2-uA energetic Xe+ reduced mirror reflectivity by only 18.7%, as opposed to the 48.5% and 41.7% decreases observed with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, respectively. For the Ru mirrors, the higher 1000eV Xe+ irradiation lowered the reflectivity by 41.6%, while the 500eV and 100eV energy decreased the reflectivity by 44.9% and 51.4% respectively. In-situ low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy (LEISS) monitored the Sn surface fraction. For Rh samples irradiated with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, the fraction was 1 throughout the experiment. The third sample (1.2-uA) initially had a 0.71 surface fraction, which increased towards 1, dropped to 0.48 after 18 minutes, and then continued rising to 0.8 after 36 minutes. The drop suggests a threshold, where perhaps surface structure abruptly changed, that was too high for the other samples to cross. The results imply that at certain fluences, debris bombardment may not be as detrimental to collector mirror EUV reflectivity as at others. For the Ru samples, the Sn surface fraction jumped to 100% for the sample irradiated at 100eV Xe+, to 85% for the 500eV case, and 75% for the 1keV case. The reflectivity was worse with the 100eV sample, with a drop of 51.4%, while the 500eV and 1keV had drops of 44.9% and 41.6%, respectively. Morphology analyses with an atomic force microscope at Purdue University's Radiation Surface and Interface Science Laboratory revealed that the morphology of the mirror surface plays a key role in the reflectivity performance of the Rh and Ru mirrors.",
keywords = "Atomic force microscopy, EUV reflectivity, Grazing incidence collector, Ruthenium, Sn debris, Sputtering",
author = "Allain, {J. P.} and B. Holybee and M. List and A. Kacic and M. Nieto-Perez and Hendricks, {M. R.}",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1117/12.888369",
isbn = "9780819486677",
volume = "8077",
booktitle = "Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Particle-induced damage effects on extreme UV (13.5-nm) source collector mirror optics

AU - Allain,J. P.

AU - Holybee,B.

AU - List,M.

AU - Kacic,A.

AU - Nieto-Perez,M.

AU - Hendricks,M. R.

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light at 13.5 nm is a candidate for advanced optical lithography where sub-32 nm features will spawn the next generation of microchips. Plasma-based Sn sources have been used to generate EUV light, but debris contamination and damage limits the life expectancy of plasma-facing collector optics. Although mitigation systems reduce the amount of vapor, thermal and energetic particles still reach mirror surfaces. Three Rh mirror samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic 1 keV Xe+ (12-nA, 120-nA, and 1.2-uA) particles for 36 minutes and three Ru samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic Xe+ (100eV, 500eV, and 1000eV). In-situ measurements of EUV reflectivity and surface composition were correlated with ex-situ morphology investigations. For the Rh mirrors, a combination of 14.7-nA thermal Sn and 1.2-uA energetic Xe+ reduced mirror reflectivity by only 18.7%, as opposed to the 48.5% and 41.7% decreases observed with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, respectively. For the Ru mirrors, the higher 1000eV Xe+ irradiation lowered the reflectivity by 41.6%, while the 500eV and 100eV energy decreased the reflectivity by 44.9% and 51.4% respectively. In-situ low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy (LEISS) monitored the Sn surface fraction. For Rh samples irradiated with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, the fraction was 1 throughout the experiment. The third sample (1.2-uA) initially had a 0.71 surface fraction, which increased towards 1, dropped to 0.48 after 18 minutes, and then continued rising to 0.8 after 36 minutes. The drop suggests a threshold, where perhaps surface structure abruptly changed, that was too high for the other samples to cross. The results imply that at certain fluences, debris bombardment may not be as detrimental to collector mirror EUV reflectivity as at others. For the Ru samples, the Sn surface fraction jumped to 100% for the sample irradiated at 100eV Xe+, to 85% for the 500eV case, and 75% for the 1keV case. The reflectivity was worse with the 100eV sample, with a drop of 51.4%, while the 500eV and 1keV had drops of 44.9% and 41.6%, respectively. Morphology analyses with an atomic force microscope at Purdue University's Radiation Surface and Interface Science Laboratory revealed that the morphology of the mirror surface plays a key role in the reflectivity performance of the Rh and Ru mirrors.

AB - Extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light at 13.5 nm is a candidate for advanced optical lithography where sub-32 nm features will spawn the next generation of microchips. Plasma-based Sn sources have been used to generate EUV light, but debris contamination and damage limits the life expectancy of plasma-facing collector optics. Although mitigation systems reduce the amount of vapor, thermal and energetic particles still reach mirror surfaces. Three Rh mirror samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic 1 keV Xe+ (12-nA, 120-nA, and 1.2-uA) particles for 36 minutes and three Ru samples were exposed to thermal Sn (14.7-nA) and energetic Xe+ (100eV, 500eV, and 1000eV). In-situ measurements of EUV reflectivity and surface composition were correlated with ex-situ morphology investigations. For the Rh mirrors, a combination of 14.7-nA thermal Sn and 1.2-uA energetic Xe+ reduced mirror reflectivity by only 18.7%, as opposed to the 48.5% and 41.7% decreases observed with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, respectively. For the Ru mirrors, the higher 1000eV Xe+ irradiation lowered the reflectivity by 41.6%, while the 500eV and 100eV energy decreased the reflectivity by 44.9% and 51.4% respectively. In-situ low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy (LEISS) monitored the Sn surface fraction. For Rh samples irradiated with 120-nA and 12-nA energetic Xe+, the fraction was 1 throughout the experiment. The third sample (1.2-uA) initially had a 0.71 surface fraction, which increased towards 1, dropped to 0.48 after 18 minutes, and then continued rising to 0.8 after 36 minutes. The drop suggests a threshold, where perhaps surface structure abruptly changed, that was too high for the other samples to cross. The results imply that at certain fluences, debris bombardment may not be as detrimental to collector mirror EUV reflectivity as at others. For the Ru samples, the Sn surface fraction jumped to 100% for the sample irradiated at 100eV Xe+, to 85% for the 500eV case, and 75% for the 1keV case. The reflectivity was worse with the 100eV sample, with a drop of 51.4%, while the 500eV and 1keV had drops of 44.9% and 41.6%, respectively. Morphology analyses with an atomic force microscope at Purdue University's Radiation Surface and Interface Science Laboratory revealed that the morphology of the mirror surface plays a key role in the reflectivity performance of the Rh and Ru mirrors.

KW - Atomic force microscopy

KW - EUV reflectivity

KW - Grazing incidence collector

KW - Ruthenium

KW - Sn debris

KW - Sputtering

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79960545892&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79960545892&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1117/12.888369

DO - 10.1117/12.888369

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 9780819486677

VL - 8077

BT - Damage to VUV, EUV, and X-Ray Optics III

ER -