Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption

Mark E. Lundy, Cameron M. Pittelkow, Bruce A. Linquist, Xinqiang Liang, Kees Jan van Groenigen, Juhwan Lee, Johan Six, Rodney T. Venterea, Chris van Kessel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Conservation agriculture (CA) has been promoted as a method of sustainable intensification and climate change mitigation and is being widely practiced and implemented globally. However, no-till (NT), a fundamental component of CA, has been shown to reduce yields in many cases. In order to maintain yields following adoption of CA, it has been recently suggested that fertilizer application should be an integral component of CA. To determine the contribution of nitrogen (N) fertilizer in minimizing yield declines following NT implementation, we assessed 2759 paired comparisons of NT and conventional tillage (CT) systems from 325 studies reported in the peer-reviewed literature between 1980 and 2013. Overall, we found that NT yields decreased -10.7% (-14.8% to -6.5%) and -3.7% (-5.3% to -2.2%) relative to CT in tropical/subtropical and temperate regions, respectively. Among management and environmental variables that included: the rate of N fertilization; the duration of the NT/CT comparison; residue, rotation, and irrigation practices; the crop type; and the site aridity, N rate was the most important explanatory variable for NT yield declines in tropical/subtropical regions. In temperate regions, N fertilization rates were relatively less important. NT yield declines were most consistently observed at low rates of N fertilization during the first 2 years of NT adoption in tropical/subtropical regions. Applications of N fertilizer at rates of up to 85±12kgNha-1yr-1 significantly reduced NT yield declines in these scenarios. While this result should not be viewed as a rate recommendation, it does suggest that farmers applying rates of N fertilizer that are low for their specific system will, on average, see higher NT yields if they increase application rates. In addition, when crop rotation was not practiced or residues were removed from the field, NT yield declines were magnified by low rates of N fertilization in tropical/subtropical regions. These results, based on a global data set and across a broad range of crops, highlight the importance of N fertilization in counteracting yield declines in NT systems, particularly in tropical/subtropical regions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)204-210
Number of pages7
JournalField Crops Research
Volume183
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2015

Fingerprint

no-tillage
nitrogen
subtropical region
tropical region
subtropics
tillage
agriculture
nitrogen fertilizers
conventional tillage
fertilizer
rate
crop
crop rotation
aridity
fertilizer application
dry environmental conditions
peers
crops
irrigation
application rate

Keywords

  • Meta-analysis
  • Nitrogen fertilizer
  • No-till duration
  • Residue
  • Rotation
  • Temperate
  • Tillage
  • Tropical/subtropical

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Soil Science

Cite this

Lundy, M. E., Pittelkow, C. M., Linquist, B. A., Liang, X., van Groenigen, K. J., Lee, J., ... van Kessel, C. (2015). Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption. Field Crops Research, 183, 204-210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.023

Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption. / Lundy, Mark E.; Pittelkow, Cameron M.; Linquist, Bruce A.; Liang, Xinqiang; van Groenigen, Kees Jan; Lee, Juhwan; Six, Johan; Venterea, Rodney T.; van Kessel, Chris.

In: Field Crops Research, Vol. 183, 01.11.2015, p. 204-210.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lundy, ME, Pittelkow, CM, Linquist, BA, Liang, X, van Groenigen, KJ, Lee, J, Six, J, Venterea, RT & van Kessel, C 2015, 'Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption', Field Crops Research, vol. 183, pp. 204-210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.023
Lundy, Mark E. ; Pittelkow, Cameron M. ; Linquist, Bruce A. ; Liang, Xinqiang ; van Groenigen, Kees Jan ; Lee, Juhwan ; Six, Johan ; Venterea, Rodney T. ; van Kessel, Chris. / Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption. In: Field Crops Research. 2015 ; Vol. 183. pp. 204-210.
@article{2db2343394854dd788fa28900ad2d440,
title = "Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption",
abstract = "Conservation agriculture (CA) has been promoted as a method of sustainable intensification and climate change mitigation and is being widely practiced and implemented globally. However, no-till (NT), a fundamental component of CA, has been shown to reduce yields in many cases. In order to maintain yields following adoption of CA, it has been recently suggested that fertilizer application should be an integral component of CA. To determine the contribution of nitrogen (N) fertilizer in minimizing yield declines following NT implementation, we assessed 2759 paired comparisons of NT and conventional tillage (CT) systems from 325 studies reported in the peer-reviewed literature between 1980 and 2013. Overall, we found that NT yields decreased -10.7{\%} (-14.8{\%} to -6.5{\%}) and -3.7{\%} (-5.3{\%} to -2.2{\%}) relative to CT in tropical/subtropical and temperate regions, respectively. Among management and environmental variables that included: the rate of N fertilization; the duration of the NT/CT comparison; residue, rotation, and irrigation practices; the crop type; and the site aridity, N rate was the most important explanatory variable for NT yield declines in tropical/subtropical regions. In temperate regions, N fertilization rates were relatively less important. NT yield declines were most consistently observed at low rates of N fertilization during the first 2 years of NT adoption in tropical/subtropical regions. Applications of N fertilizer at rates of up to 85±12kgNha-1yr-1 significantly reduced NT yield declines in these scenarios. While this result should not be viewed as a rate recommendation, it does suggest that farmers applying rates of N fertilizer that are low for their specific system will, on average, see higher NT yields if they increase application rates. In addition, when crop rotation was not practiced or residues were removed from the field, NT yield declines were magnified by low rates of N fertilization in tropical/subtropical regions. These results, based on a global data set and across a broad range of crops, highlight the importance of N fertilization in counteracting yield declines in NT systems, particularly in tropical/subtropical regions.",
keywords = "Meta-analysis, Nitrogen fertilizer, No-till duration, Residue, Rotation, Temperate, Tillage, Tropical/subtropical",
author = "Lundy, {Mark E.} and Pittelkow, {Cameron M.} and Linquist, {Bruce A.} and Xinqiang Liang and {van Groenigen}, {Kees Jan} and Juhwan Lee and Johan Six and Venterea, {Rodney T.} and {van Kessel}, Chris",
year = "2015",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.023",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "183",
pages = "204--210",
journal = "Field Crops Research",
issn = "0378-4290",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nitrogen fertilization reduces yield declines following no-till adoption

AU - Lundy, Mark E.

AU - Pittelkow, Cameron M.

AU - Linquist, Bruce A.

AU - Liang, Xinqiang

AU - van Groenigen, Kees Jan

AU - Lee, Juhwan

AU - Six, Johan

AU - Venterea, Rodney T.

AU - van Kessel, Chris

PY - 2015/11/1

Y1 - 2015/11/1

N2 - Conservation agriculture (CA) has been promoted as a method of sustainable intensification and climate change mitigation and is being widely practiced and implemented globally. However, no-till (NT), a fundamental component of CA, has been shown to reduce yields in many cases. In order to maintain yields following adoption of CA, it has been recently suggested that fertilizer application should be an integral component of CA. To determine the contribution of nitrogen (N) fertilizer in minimizing yield declines following NT implementation, we assessed 2759 paired comparisons of NT and conventional tillage (CT) systems from 325 studies reported in the peer-reviewed literature between 1980 and 2013. Overall, we found that NT yields decreased -10.7% (-14.8% to -6.5%) and -3.7% (-5.3% to -2.2%) relative to CT in tropical/subtropical and temperate regions, respectively. Among management and environmental variables that included: the rate of N fertilization; the duration of the NT/CT comparison; residue, rotation, and irrigation practices; the crop type; and the site aridity, N rate was the most important explanatory variable for NT yield declines in tropical/subtropical regions. In temperate regions, N fertilization rates were relatively less important. NT yield declines were most consistently observed at low rates of N fertilization during the first 2 years of NT adoption in tropical/subtropical regions. Applications of N fertilizer at rates of up to 85±12kgNha-1yr-1 significantly reduced NT yield declines in these scenarios. While this result should not be viewed as a rate recommendation, it does suggest that farmers applying rates of N fertilizer that are low for their specific system will, on average, see higher NT yields if they increase application rates. In addition, when crop rotation was not practiced or residues were removed from the field, NT yield declines were magnified by low rates of N fertilization in tropical/subtropical regions. These results, based on a global data set and across a broad range of crops, highlight the importance of N fertilization in counteracting yield declines in NT systems, particularly in tropical/subtropical regions.

AB - Conservation agriculture (CA) has been promoted as a method of sustainable intensification and climate change mitigation and is being widely practiced and implemented globally. However, no-till (NT), a fundamental component of CA, has been shown to reduce yields in many cases. In order to maintain yields following adoption of CA, it has been recently suggested that fertilizer application should be an integral component of CA. To determine the contribution of nitrogen (N) fertilizer in minimizing yield declines following NT implementation, we assessed 2759 paired comparisons of NT and conventional tillage (CT) systems from 325 studies reported in the peer-reviewed literature between 1980 and 2013. Overall, we found that NT yields decreased -10.7% (-14.8% to -6.5%) and -3.7% (-5.3% to -2.2%) relative to CT in tropical/subtropical and temperate regions, respectively. Among management and environmental variables that included: the rate of N fertilization; the duration of the NT/CT comparison; residue, rotation, and irrigation practices; the crop type; and the site aridity, N rate was the most important explanatory variable for NT yield declines in tropical/subtropical regions. In temperate regions, N fertilization rates were relatively less important. NT yield declines were most consistently observed at low rates of N fertilization during the first 2 years of NT adoption in tropical/subtropical regions. Applications of N fertilizer at rates of up to 85±12kgNha-1yr-1 significantly reduced NT yield declines in these scenarios. While this result should not be viewed as a rate recommendation, it does suggest that farmers applying rates of N fertilizer that are low for their specific system will, on average, see higher NT yields if they increase application rates. In addition, when crop rotation was not practiced or residues were removed from the field, NT yield declines were magnified by low rates of N fertilization in tropical/subtropical regions. These results, based on a global data set and across a broad range of crops, highlight the importance of N fertilization in counteracting yield declines in NT systems, particularly in tropical/subtropical regions.

KW - Meta-analysis

KW - Nitrogen fertilizer

KW - No-till duration

KW - Residue

KW - Rotation

KW - Temperate

KW - Tillage

KW - Tropical/subtropical

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84939443432&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84939443432&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.023

DO - 10.1016/j.fcr.2015.07.023

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84939443432

VL - 183

SP - 204

EP - 210

JO - Field Crops Research

JF - Field Crops Research

SN - 0378-4290

ER -