Multi-objective optimization for sustainable renewable jet fuel production: A case study of corn stover based supply chain system in Midwestern U.S.

Endai Huang, Xiaolei Zhang, Luis F Rodriguez, Madhu Khanna, Sierk de Jong, K. C. Ting, Yibin Ying, Tao Lin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Sustainable development of biomass-based renewable jet fuel (RJF) production mitigates the environmental stress and improves rural economics. We develop a mixed-integer linear programming model to incorporate spatial, agricultural, techno-economical, and environmental data for multi-objective optimization of RJF supply chain systems. The model is applied to the Midwestern U.S. to evaluate the sustainability performance of three pathways including alcohol-to-jet (ATJ), Fischer-Tropsch (FT) and Hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). The results show that HTL is the most cost-effective with a cost of $4.64/gal while FT is most environmental-friendly with the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of 0.10 kg CO2/gal. The cost-optimal analysis suggests a centralized supply chain configuration with large facilities, while the environmental optimization analysis prefers a distributed system with small biorefinery facilities. For FT approach, cost optimization analysis suggests developing a supply chain with one large biorefinery, whereas environmental optimization prefers a system with 11 small biorefineries. Considering the economic and environmental factors simultaneously, the Pareto curve demonstrates that total production costs of three pathways all increase with the more stringent constraints of GHG emissions. This indicates that RJF production costs are sensitive to the regulation of GHG emissions. Considering the carbon price at $0.22 per kg of CO2 reduction, FT yields the lowest cost of $2.83/gal among three pathways, but it is still 47% higher than that of fossil jet fuel. FT is not cost competitive with fossil jet fuel until the carbon price increases to $0.30 per kg of CO2 reduction. FT is suggested a promising sustainable RJF production pathway due to its relatively low capital investment and production costs, centralized supply chain configuration, and low GHG emissions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number109403
JournalRenewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
Volume115
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2019

Fingerprint

Jet fuel
Multiobjective optimization
Supply chains
Gas emissions
Greenhouse gases
Costs
Liquefaction
Fossil fuels
Sustainable development
Economics
Carbon
Linear programming
Biomass
Alcohols

Keywords

  • Cost
  • Greenhouse gas emission
  • Mixed-integer linear programming
  • Multi-objective optimization
  • Pareto-optimal curve
  • Renewable jet fuel
  • Supply chain optimization

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment

Cite this

Multi-objective optimization for sustainable renewable jet fuel production : A case study of corn stover based supply chain system in Midwestern U.S. / Huang, Endai; Zhang, Xiaolei; Rodriguez, Luis F; Khanna, Madhu; de Jong, Sierk; Ting, K. C.; Ying, Yibin; Lin, Tao.

In: Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 115, 109403, 11.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{420329b184294280aaa0097e10af8e52,
title = "Multi-objective optimization for sustainable renewable jet fuel production: A case study of corn stover based supply chain system in Midwestern U.S.",
abstract = "Sustainable development of biomass-based renewable jet fuel (RJF) production mitigates the environmental stress and improves rural economics. We develop a mixed-integer linear programming model to incorporate spatial, agricultural, techno-economical, and environmental data for multi-objective optimization of RJF supply chain systems. The model is applied to the Midwestern U.S. to evaluate the sustainability performance of three pathways including alcohol-to-jet (ATJ), Fischer-Tropsch (FT) and Hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). The results show that HTL is the most cost-effective with a cost of $4.64/gal while FT is most environmental-friendly with the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of 0.10 kg CO2/gal. The cost-optimal analysis suggests a centralized supply chain configuration with large facilities, while the environmental optimization analysis prefers a distributed system with small biorefinery facilities. For FT approach, cost optimization analysis suggests developing a supply chain with one large biorefinery, whereas environmental optimization prefers a system with 11 small biorefineries. Considering the economic and environmental factors simultaneously, the Pareto curve demonstrates that total production costs of three pathways all increase with the more stringent constraints of GHG emissions. This indicates that RJF production costs are sensitive to the regulation of GHG emissions. Considering the carbon price at $0.22 per kg of CO2 reduction, FT yields the lowest cost of $2.83/gal among three pathways, but it is still 47{\%} higher than that of fossil jet fuel. FT is not cost competitive with fossil jet fuel until the carbon price increases to $0.30 per kg of CO2 reduction. FT is suggested a promising sustainable RJF production pathway due to its relatively low capital investment and production costs, centralized supply chain configuration, and low GHG emissions.",
keywords = "Cost, Greenhouse gas emission, Mixed-integer linear programming, Multi-objective optimization, Pareto-optimal curve, Renewable jet fuel, Supply chain optimization",
author = "Endai Huang and Xiaolei Zhang and Rodriguez, {Luis F} and Madhu Khanna and {de Jong}, Sierk and Ting, {K. C.} and Yibin Ying and Tao Lin",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.rser.2019.109403",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "115",
journal = "Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews",
issn = "1364-0321",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multi-objective optimization for sustainable renewable jet fuel production

T2 - A case study of corn stover based supply chain system in Midwestern U.S.

AU - Huang, Endai

AU - Zhang, Xiaolei

AU - Rodriguez, Luis F

AU - Khanna, Madhu

AU - de Jong, Sierk

AU - Ting, K. C.

AU - Ying, Yibin

AU - Lin, Tao

PY - 2019/11

Y1 - 2019/11

N2 - Sustainable development of biomass-based renewable jet fuel (RJF) production mitigates the environmental stress and improves rural economics. We develop a mixed-integer linear programming model to incorporate spatial, agricultural, techno-economical, and environmental data for multi-objective optimization of RJF supply chain systems. The model is applied to the Midwestern U.S. to evaluate the sustainability performance of three pathways including alcohol-to-jet (ATJ), Fischer-Tropsch (FT) and Hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). The results show that HTL is the most cost-effective with a cost of $4.64/gal while FT is most environmental-friendly with the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of 0.10 kg CO2/gal. The cost-optimal analysis suggests a centralized supply chain configuration with large facilities, while the environmental optimization analysis prefers a distributed system with small biorefinery facilities. For FT approach, cost optimization analysis suggests developing a supply chain with one large biorefinery, whereas environmental optimization prefers a system with 11 small biorefineries. Considering the economic and environmental factors simultaneously, the Pareto curve demonstrates that total production costs of three pathways all increase with the more stringent constraints of GHG emissions. This indicates that RJF production costs are sensitive to the regulation of GHG emissions. Considering the carbon price at $0.22 per kg of CO2 reduction, FT yields the lowest cost of $2.83/gal among three pathways, but it is still 47% higher than that of fossil jet fuel. FT is not cost competitive with fossil jet fuel until the carbon price increases to $0.30 per kg of CO2 reduction. FT is suggested a promising sustainable RJF production pathway due to its relatively low capital investment and production costs, centralized supply chain configuration, and low GHG emissions.

AB - Sustainable development of biomass-based renewable jet fuel (RJF) production mitigates the environmental stress and improves rural economics. We develop a mixed-integer linear programming model to incorporate spatial, agricultural, techno-economical, and environmental data for multi-objective optimization of RJF supply chain systems. The model is applied to the Midwestern U.S. to evaluate the sustainability performance of three pathways including alcohol-to-jet (ATJ), Fischer-Tropsch (FT) and Hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL). The results show that HTL is the most cost-effective with a cost of $4.64/gal while FT is most environmental-friendly with the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of 0.10 kg CO2/gal. The cost-optimal analysis suggests a centralized supply chain configuration with large facilities, while the environmental optimization analysis prefers a distributed system with small biorefinery facilities. For FT approach, cost optimization analysis suggests developing a supply chain with one large biorefinery, whereas environmental optimization prefers a system with 11 small biorefineries. Considering the economic and environmental factors simultaneously, the Pareto curve demonstrates that total production costs of three pathways all increase with the more stringent constraints of GHG emissions. This indicates that RJF production costs are sensitive to the regulation of GHG emissions. Considering the carbon price at $0.22 per kg of CO2 reduction, FT yields the lowest cost of $2.83/gal among three pathways, but it is still 47% higher than that of fossil jet fuel. FT is not cost competitive with fossil jet fuel until the carbon price increases to $0.30 per kg of CO2 reduction. FT is suggested a promising sustainable RJF production pathway due to its relatively low capital investment and production costs, centralized supply chain configuration, and low GHG emissions.

KW - Cost

KW - Greenhouse gas emission

KW - Mixed-integer linear programming

KW - Multi-objective optimization

KW - Pareto-optimal curve

KW - Renewable jet fuel

KW - Supply chain optimization

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85072401262&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85072401262&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.rser.2019.109403

DO - 10.1016/j.rser.2019.109403

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85072401262

VL - 115

JO - Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

JF - Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

SN - 1364-0321

M1 - 109403

ER -