Innovations in Discovery Systems: User Studies and the Bento Approach

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Over the past 30 years, library discovery services have evolved through expanded OPACs, federated search systems employing broadcast searching; Web-scale discovery systems (WSDS) that aggregate metadata and full-text content into a single integrated index; and, currently, hybrid bento-style systems that use federated techniques over WSDS, OPACs, and local information content. The bento systems partition search results into separate zoned screen displays grouped by content format type and/or local service results. Recent studies on Web-scale discovery systems have identified a number of user access issues centering on problems with blended result displays, problematical relevancy rankings of search results, full-text search problems, and the inability of WSDS to adequately provide access to local library services and resources. The concept of “full library discovery,” a phrase first coined by Lorcan Dempsey, has been introduced to refer to discovery approaches that move beyond the retrieval of collection materials to also include local information services and local content and links. The bento-based systems are an attempt to address the identified problems with WSDS and also provide discovery services that address user needs, in particular known item search and streamlined full-text access. This presentation will provide an analysis of the 38 libraries presently employing the bento approach and will look at identified user needs and search behaviors, as revealed in detailed search and clickthrough transaction log analyses. There is a clear need for an evidence-based analysis of user search behaviors in retrieval environments characterized by access to distributed information resources.
Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationWhat’s Past is Prologue
Subtitle of host publicationProceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference
EditorsBeth R. Bernhardt, Leah Hinds, Lars Meyer
PublisherPurdue University Press
Pages299-304
DOIs
StatePublished - 2018
EventCharleston Library Conference - Charleston, United States
Duration: Nov 5 2017Nov 9 2017
http://www.charlestonlibraryconference.com

Conference

ConferenceCharleston Library Conference
CountryUnited States
CityCharleston
Period11/5/1711/9/17
Internet address

Fingerprint

innovation
information content
information service
broadcast
resources
transaction
ranking
evidence

Cite this

Mischo, W., Norman, M., & Schlembach, M. (2018). Innovations in Discovery Systems: User Studies and the Bento Approach. In B. R. Bernhardt, L. Hinds, & L. Meyer (Eds.), What’s Past is Prologue: Proceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference (pp. 299-304). Purdue University Press. https://doi.org/10.5703/1288284316700

Innovations in Discovery Systems : User Studies and the Bento Approach. / Mischo, William; Norman, Michael; Schlembach, Mary.

What’s Past is Prologue: Proceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference. ed. / Beth R. Bernhardt; Leah Hinds; Lars Meyer. Purdue University Press, 2018. p. 299-304.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Mischo, W, Norman, M & Schlembach, M 2018, Innovations in Discovery Systems: User Studies and the Bento Approach. in BR Bernhardt, L Hinds & L Meyer (eds), What’s Past is Prologue: Proceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference. Purdue University Press, pp. 299-304, Charleston Library Conference, Charleston, United States, 11/5/17. https://doi.org/10.5703/1288284316700
Mischo W, Norman M, Schlembach M. Innovations in Discovery Systems: User Studies and the Bento Approach. In Bernhardt BR, Hinds L, Meyer L, editors, What’s Past is Prologue: Proceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference. Purdue University Press. 2018. p. 299-304 https://doi.org/10.5703/1288284316700
Mischo, William ; Norman, Michael ; Schlembach, Mary. / Innovations in Discovery Systems : User Studies and the Bento Approach. What’s Past is Prologue: Proceedings of the 37th Charleston Conference. editor / Beth R. Bernhardt ; Leah Hinds ; Lars Meyer. Purdue University Press, 2018. pp. 299-304
@inproceedings{a9a1b512f6c44e4ebdc9bd901f77feed,
title = "Innovations in Discovery Systems: User Studies and the Bento Approach",
abstract = "Over the past 30 years, library discovery services have evolved through expanded OPACs, federated search systems employing broadcast searching; Web-scale discovery systems (WSDS) that aggregate metadata and full-text content into a single integrated index; and, currently, hybrid bento-style systems that use federated techniques over WSDS, OPACs, and local information content. The bento systems partition search results into separate zoned screen displays grouped by content format type and/or local service results. Recent studies on Web-scale discovery systems have identified a number of user access issues centering on problems with blended result displays, problematical relevancy rankings of search results, full-text search problems, and the inability of WSDS to adequately provide access to local library services and resources. The concept of “full library discovery,” a phrase first coined by Lorcan Dempsey, has been introduced to refer to discovery approaches that move beyond the retrieval of collection materials to also include local information services and local content and links. The bento-based systems are an attempt to address the identified problems with WSDS and also provide discovery services that address user needs, in particular known item search and streamlined full-text access. This presentation will provide an analysis of the 38 libraries presently employing the bento approach and will look at identified user needs and search behaviors, as revealed in detailed search and clickthrough transaction log analyses. There is a clear need for an evidence-based analysis of user search behaviors in retrieval environments characterized by access to distributed information resources.",
author = "William Mischo and Michael Norman and Mary Schlembach",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.5703/1288284316700",
language = "English (US)",
pages = "299--304",
editor = "Bernhardt, {Beth R.} and Leah Hinds and Lars Meyer",
booktitle = "What’s Past is Prologue",
publisher = "Purdue University Press",
address = "United States",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Innovations in Discovery Systems

T2 - User Studies and the Bento Approach

AU - Mischo, William

AU - Norman, Michael

AU - Schlembach, Mary

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Over the past 30 years, library discovery services have evolved through expanded OPACs, federated search systems employing broadcast searching; Web-scale discovery systems (WSDS) that aggregate metadata and full-text content into a single integrated index; and, currently, hybrid bento-style systems that use federated techniques over WSDS, OPACs, and local information content. The bento systems partition search results into separate zoned screen displays grouped by content format type and/or local service results. Recent studies on Web-scale discovery systems have identified a number of user access issues centering on problems with blended result displays, problematical relevancy rankings of search results, full-text search problems, and the inability of WSDS to adequately provide access to local library services and resources. The concept of “full library discovery,” a phrase first coined by Lorcan Dempsey, has been introduced to refer to discovery approaches that move beyond the retrieval of collection materials to also include local information services and local content and links. The bento-based systems are an attempt to address the identified problems with WSDS and also provide discovery services that address user needs, in particular known item search and streamlined full-text access. This presentation will provide an analysis of the 38 libraries presently employing the bento approach and will look at identified user needs and search behaviors, as revealed in detailed search and clickthrough transaction log analyses. There is a clear need for an evidence-based analysis of user search behaviors in retrieval environments characterized by access to distributed information resources.

AB - Over the past 30 years, library discovery services have evolved through expanded OPACs, federated search systems employing broadcast searching; Web-scale discovery systems (WSDS) that aggregate metadata and full-text content into a single integrated index; and, currently, hybrid bento-style systems that use federated techniques over WSDS, OPACs, and local information content. The bento systems partition search results into separate zoned screen displays grouped by content format type and/or local service results. Recent studies on Web-scale discovery systems have identified a number of user access issues centering on problems with blended result displays, problematical relevancy rankings of search results, full-text search problems, and the inability of WSDS to adequately provide access to local library services and resources. The concept of “full library discovery,” a phrase first coined by Lorcan Dempsey, has been introduced to refer to discovery approaches that move beyond the retrieval of collection materials to also include local information services and local content and links. The bento-based systems are an attempt to address the identified problems with WSDS and also provide discovery services that address user needs, in particular known item search and streamlined full-text access. This presentation will provide an analysis of the 38 libraries presently employing the bento approach and will look at identified user needs and search behaviors, as revealed in detailed search and clickthrough transaction log analyses. There is a clear need for an evidence-based analysis of user search behaviors in retrieval environments characterized by access to distributed information resources.

U2 - 10.5703/1288284316700

DO - 10.5703/1288284316700

M3 - Conference contribution

SP - 299

EP - 304

BT - What’s Past is Prologue

A2 - Bernhardt, Beth R.

A2 - Hinds, Leah

A2 - Meyer, Lars

PB - Purdue University Press

ER -