Dubliners: Surprised by Chance

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Readers who encounter Joyce's collection of short stories for the first time often come away with the impression that turn‐of‐the‐century Dublin was an airless world, and that Joyce mercilessly arraigns its inhabitants for their helplessness. Using taut, spare prose, Joyce shines his interrogating beam of narrative attention on one telling detail after another. This process is not interrupted by the voice of that avuncular, editorializing third‐person “omniscient” narrator we so often expect to hear when reading fiction. Instead, we are starkly confronted by selected “facts” about the lives of individual characters, and how we interpret those facts or respond to those characters is left to us. Readers tend to react to this narrative challenge in a predictable way: with boredom, avidity, depression, or moral judgment. Many readers patronize the characters as less self‐aware and functional than the readers believe themselves to be. It is easy to feel protected from Joyce's scrutiny by the fiction, which is most often experienced as a one‐way mirror rather than the “nicely polished looking‐glass” that Joyce claimed it was (LI 64). When judging the characters, readers typically exempt themselves from those judgments, thereby neglecting the opportunity to look scrupulously for the “meanness” – in the less usual sense of the term, the thread of connection or commonality – between themselves and the characters they have deprecated.1
Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationA Companion to James Joyce
EditorsRichard Brown
Place of PublicationMalden, MA
PublisherBlackwell Publishing
Pages17-33
ISBN (Electronic)9781405177535
ISBN (Print)9781405110440
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 2008

Fingerprint

Reader
Dubliners
Fiction
Boredom
Short Story
Dublin
Scrutiny
Editorialising
Narrator
Moral Judgment
Prose

Cite this

Mahaffey, V. (2008). Dubliners: Surprised by Chance. In R. Brown (Ed.), A Companion to James Joyce (pp. 17-33). Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781405177535.ch2

Dubliners : Surprised by Chance. / Mahaffey, Vicki.

A Companion to James Joyce. ed. / Richard Brown. Malden, MA : Blackwell Publishing, 2008. p. 17-33.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Mahaffey, V 2008, Dubliners: Surprised by Chance. in R Brown (ed.), A Companion to James Joyce. Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA, pp. 17-33. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781405177535.ch2
Mahaffey V. Dubliners: Surprised by Chance. In Brown R, editor, A Companion to James Joyce. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing. 2008. p. 17-33 https://doi.org/10.1002/9781405177535.ch2
Mahaffey, Vicki. / Dubliners : Surprised by Chance. A Companion to James Joyce. editor / Richard Brown. Malden, MA : Blackwell Publishing, 2008. pp. 17-33
@inbook{b38c04507c2e4630924caf860ef755e9,
title = "Dubliners: Surprised by Chance",
abstract = "Readers who encounter Joyce's collection of short stories for the first time often come away with the impression that turn‐of‐the‐century Dublin was an airless world, and that Joyce mercilessly arraigns its inhabitants for their helplessness. Using taut, spare prose, Joyce shines his interrogating beam of narrative attention on one telling detail after another. This process is not interrupted by the voice of that avuncular, editorializing third‐person “omniscient” narrator we so often expect to hear when reading fiction. Instead, we are starkly confronted by selected “facts” about the lives of individual characters, and how we interpret those facts or respond to those characters is left to us. Readers tend to react to this narrative challenge in a predictable way: with boredom, avidity, depression, or moral judgment. Many readers patronize the characters as less self‐aware and functional than the readers believe themselves to be. It is easy to feel protected from Joyce's scrutiny by the fiction, which is most often experienced as a one‐way mirror rather than the “nicely polished looking‐glass” that Joyce claimed it was (LI 64). When judging the characters, readers typically exempt themselves from those judgments, thereby neglecting the opportunity to look scrupulously for the “meanness” – in the less usual sense of the term, the thread of connection or commonality – between themselves and the characters they have deprecated.1",
author = "Vicki Mahaffey",
year = "2008",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1002/9781405177535.ch2",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9781405110440",
pages = "17--33",
editor = "Richard Brown",
booktitle = "A Companion to James Joyce",
publisher = "Blackwell Publishing",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Dubliners

T2 - Surprised by Chance

AU - Mahaffey, Vicki

PY - 2008/1

Y1 - 2008/1

N2 - Readers who encounter Joyce's collection of short stories for the first time often come away with the impression that turn‐of‐the‐century Dublin was an airless world, and that Joyce mercilessly arraigns its inhabitants for their helplessness. Using taut, spare prose, Joyce shines his interrogating beam of narrative attention on one telling detail after another. This process is not interrupted by the voice of that avuncular, editorializing third‐person “omniscient” narrator we so often expect to hear when reading fiction. Instead, we are starkly confronted by selected “facts” about the lives of individual characters, and how we interpret those facts or respond to those characters is left to us. Readers tend to react to this narrative challenge in a predictable way: with boredom, avidity, depression, or moral judgment. Many readers patronize the characters as less self‐aware and functional than the readers believe themselves to be. It is easy to feel protected from Joyce's scrutiny by the fiction, which is most often experienced as a one‐way mirror rather than the “nicely polished looking‐glass” that Joyce claimed it was (LI 64). When judging the characters, readers typically exempt themselves from those judgments, thereby neglecting the opportunity to look scrupulously for the “meanness” – in the less usual sense of the term, the thread of connection or commonality – between themselves and the characters they have deprecated.1

AB - Readers who encounter Joyce's collection of short stories for the first time often come away with the impression that turn‐of‐the‐century Dublin was an airless world, and that Joyce mercilessly arraigns its inhabitants for their helplessness. Using taut, spare prose, Joyce shines his interrogating beam of narrative attention on one telling detail after another. This process is not interrupted by the voice of that avuncular, editorializing third‐person “omniscient” narrator we so often expect to hear when reading fiction. Instead, we are starkly confronted by selected “facts” about the lives of individual characters, and how we interpret those facts or respond to those characters is left to us. Readers tend to react to this narrative challenge in a predictable way: with boredom, avidity, depression, or moral judgment. Many readers patronize the characters as less self‐aware and functional than the readers believe themselves to be. It is easy to feel protected from Joyce's scrutiny by the fiction, which is most often experienced as a one‐way mirror rather than the “nicely polished looking‐glass” that Joyce claimed it was (LI 64). When judging the characters, readers typically exempt themselves from those judgments, thereby neglecting the opportunity to look scrupulously for the “meanness” – in the less usual sense of the term, the thread of connection or commonality – between themselves and the characters they have deprecated.1

U2 - 10.1002/9781405177535.ch2

DO - 10.1002/9781405177535.ch2

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781405110440

SP - 17

EP - 33

BT - A Companion to James Joyce

A2 - Brown, Richard

PB - Blackwell Publishing

CY - Malden, MA

ER -