TY - JOUR
T1 - Hyperlocal sustainabilities
T2 - theorizing action research for sustainability in the digital age
AU - Cutts, Bethany B.
AU - Greenlee, Andrew J.
AU - Hornik, Kaitlyn
AU - Nigrelli, Caitie A.
N1 - We gratefully acknowledge funding from Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant, Grant No. NA14OAR4170095 “Mapping Social Vulnerability in EPA-designated Areas of Concern” Effort by CAN was funded by USEPA Great Lakes Restoration Initiative through USGS Award Number G16AP00001. The opinions and findings presented here are those of the authors alone. The authors would also like to thank all interview and focus group participants as well as the following individuals who provided invaluable help with creating the documentaries and discussion guides and/or conceptual discussions: Sara Barker, Betsy Breyer, Laura Bray, Ann Brummitt, Adam Carr, Carolina Chantrill, Annie Contractor, Ryan Holifield, Jeanette Lim, Jonathan London, El Lower, Jaeleen Mendoza, Jenna Minser, Jachin Moore, Deidre Peroff, Natalie Prochaska, Sierra Taliaferro, Nancy Smebak, Juliana McMillan-Wilhoit, and Rachael Wilson.
PY - 2020/1/1
Y1 - 2020/1/1
N2 - Hyperlocal relationships are internet-enabled interactions in a common locale. They are opening new frontiers for geographically based, community-oriented, and civically engaged action. However, the influences of virtual interactions over procedural aspects of sustainability projects are not fully theorized. To fill this gap, we examine whether anticipating the use of social media re-shapes how the community voice method (CVM) intervenes in deliberative spaces associated with waterway sustainability in Milwaukee, Wisconsin (USA). CVM is a video-based participatory research approach designed to foster inclusive and community-focused planning. Like most visual methods, it originated before the wide availability of interactive web 2.0 technologies. Our working hypothesis is that the intention to engage the public through online fora creates a new group of stakeholders who are poorly understood. As a result of analyzing field notes, audio-visual recordings of participants, and other documents, we find that anticipating the use of social media shapes all aspects of participation, including: awareness of context, group dynamics, interventions, outcomes of concern. Concern for the opinions and perspectives of hyperlocal participants re-shapes recommendations about how to align research projects with community needs and planning deliberation. Social media is an important outlet for the work, but changed the placement of video products in relation to waterway sustainability plans, especially with respect to environmental justice. We conclude by proposing a framework for hyperlocal sustainability research that appropriately emphasizes justice.
AB - Hyperlocal relationships are internet-enabled interactions in a common locale. They are opening new frontiers for geographically based, community-oriented, and civically engaged action. However, the influences of virtual interactions over procedural aspects of sustainability projects are not fully theorized. To fill this gap, we examine whether anticipating the use of social media re-shapes how the community voice method (CVM) intervenes in deliberative spaces associated with waterway sustainability in Milwaukee, Wisconsin (USA). CVM is a video-based participatory research approach designed to foster inclusive and community-focused planning. Like most visual methods, it originated before the wide availability of interactive web 2.0 technologies. Our working hypothesis is that the intention to engage the public through online fora creates a new group of stakeholders who are poorly understood. As a result of analyzing field notes, audio-visual recordings of participants, and other documents, we find that anticipating the use of social media shapes all aspects of participation, including: awareness of context, group dynamics, interventions, outcomes of concern. Concern for the opinions and perspectives of hyperlocal participants re-shapes recommendations about how to align research projects with community needs and planning deliberation. Social media is an important outlet for the work, but changed the placement of video products in relation to waterway sustainability plans, especially with respect to environmental justice. We conclude by proposing a framework for hyperlocal sustainability research that appropriately emphasizes justice.
KW - Community-based participatory research
KW - Digital society
KW - Environmental justice
KW - Internet
KW - Social justice
KW - Social media
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064606611&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85064606611&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1007/s11625-019-00694-9
DO - 10.1007/s11625-019-00694-9
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85064606611
SN - 1862-4065
VL - 15
SP - 315
EP - 331
JO - Sustainability Science
JF - Sustainability Science
IS - 1
ER -