Froude scaling limitations in modeling of turbidity currents

Jasim Imran, Sadia M. Khan, Carlos Pirmez, Gary Parker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The scaling problem associated with the modeling of turbidity currents has been recognized but is yet to be explored systematically. This paper presents an analysis of the dimensionless governing equations of turbidity currents to investigate the scale effect. Three types of flow conditions are considered: (i) conservative density current; (ii) purely depositional turbidity current; and (iii) mixed erosional/depositional turbidity current. Two controlling dimensionless numbers, the Froude number and the Reynolds number, appear in the non-dimensional governing equations. When densimetric Froude similarity is satisfied, the analysis shows that the results would be scale-invariant for conservative density current under the rough turbulent condition. In the case of purely depositional flows, truly scale-invariant results cannot be obtained, as the Reynolds-mediated scale effects appear in the bottom boundary conditions of the flow velocity and sediment fall velocity. However, the scale effect would be relatively modest. The Reynolds effect becomes more significant for erosional or mixed erosional/depositional turbidity currents as Reynolds-mediated scale effects also appear in the sediment entrainment relation. Numerical simulations have been conducted at three different scales by considering densimetric Froude scaling alone as well as combined densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarity. Simulation results confirm that although the scaling of densimetric Froude number alone can produce scale-invariable results for conservative density currents, variations occur in the case of turbidity currents. The results become scale invariant when densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarities are satisfied simultaneously.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)159-186
Number of pages28
JournalEnvironmental Fluid Mechanics
Volume17
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2017

Fingerprint

turbidity current
Turbidity
scale effect
density current
modeling
Froude number
Current density
Sediments
dimensionless number
Reynolds number
Flow velocity
entrainment
flow velocity
sediment
simulation
boundary condition
Boundary conditions
Computer simulation

Keywords

  • Densimetric Froude number
  • Froude number
  • Numerical modeling
  • Particle Reynolds number
  • Reynolds number
  • Scale effect
  • Turbidity currents
  • Turbulence modeling

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Chemistry
  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

Froude scaling limitations in modeling of turbidity currents. / Imran, Jasim; Khan, Sadia M.; Pirmez, Carlos; Parker, Gary.

In: Environmental Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 17, No. 1, 01.02.2017, p. 159-186.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Imran, Jasim ; Khan, Sadia M. ; Pirmez, Carlos ; Parker, Gary. / Froude scaling limitations in modeling of turbidity currents. In: Environmental Fluid Mechanics. 2017 ; Vol. 17, No. 1. pp. 159-186.
@article{6c3e49d6a2b94e8d8b9ea82ef2f7193d,
title = "Froude scaling limitations in modeling of turbidity currents",
abstract = "The scaling problem associated with the modeling of turbidity currents has been recognized but is yet to be explored systematically. This paper presents an analysis of the dimensionless governing equations of turbidity currents to investigate the scale effect. Three types of flow conditions are considered: (i) conservative density current; (ii) purely depositional turbidity current; and (iii) mixed erosional/depositional turbidity current. Two controlling dimensionless numbers, the Froude number and the Reynolds number, appear in the non-dimensional governing equations. When densimetric Froude similarity is satisfied, the analysis shows that the results would be scale-invariant for conservative density current under the rough turbulent condition. In the case of purely depositional flows, truly scale-invariant results cannot be obtained, as the Reynolds-mediated scale effects appear in the bottom boundary conditions of the flow velocity and sediment fall velocity. However, the scale effect would be relatively modest. The Reynolds effect becomes more significant for erosional or mixed erosional/depositional turbidity currents as Reynolds-mediated scale effects also appear in the sediment entrainment relation. Numerical simulations have been conducted at three different scales by considering densimetric Froude scaling alone as well as combined densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarity. Simulation results confirm that although the scaling of densimetric Froude number alone can produce scale-invariable results for conservative density currents, variations occur in the case of turbidity currents. The results become scale invariant when densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarities are satisfied simultaneously.",
keywords = "Densimetric Froude number, Froude number, Numerical modeling, Particle Reynolds number, Reynolds number, Scale effect, Turbidity currents, Turbulence modeling",
author = "Jasim Imran and Khan, {Sadia M.} and Carlos Pirmez and Gary Parker",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s10652-016-9488-6",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "17",
pages = "159--186",
journal = "Environmental Fluid Mechanics",
issn = "1567-7419",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Froude scaling limitations in modeling of turbidity currents

AU - Imran, Jasim

AU - Khan, Sadia M.

AU - Pirmez, Carlos

AU - Parker, Gary

PY - 2017/2/1

Y1 - 2017/2/1

N2 - The scaling problem associated with the modeling of turbidity currents has been recognized but is yet to be explored systematically. This paper presents an analysis of the dimensionless governing equations of turbidity currents to investigate the scale effect. Three types of flow conditions are considered: (i) conservative density current; (ii) purely depositional turbidity current; and (iii) mixed erosional/depositional turbidity current. Two controlling dimensionless numbers, the Froude number and the Reynolds number, appear in the non-dimensional governing equations. When densimetric Froude similarity is satisfied, the analysis shows that the results would be scale-invariant for conservative density current under the rough turbulent condition. In the case of purely depositional flows, truly scale-invariant results cannot be obtained, as the Reynolds-mediated scale effects appear in the bottom boundary conditions of the flow velocity and sediment fall velocity. However, the scale effect would be relatively modest. The Reynolds effect becomes more significant for erosional or mixed erosional/depositional turbidity currents as Reynolds-mediated scale effects also appear in the sediment entrainment relation. Numerical simulations have been conducted at three different scales by considering densimetric Froude scaling alone as well as combined densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarity. Simulation results confirm that although the scaling of densimetric Froude number alone can produce scale-invariable results for conservative density currents, variations occur in the case of turbidity currents. The results become scale invariant when densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarities are satisfied simultaneously.

AB - The scaling problem associated with the modeling of turbidity currents has been recognized but is yet to be explored systematically. This paper presents an analysis of the dimensionless governing equations of turbidity currents to investigate the scale effect. Three types of flow conditions are considered: (i) conservative density current; (ii) purely depositional turbidity current; and (iii) mixed erosional/depositional turbidity current. Two controlling dimensionless numbers, the Froude number and the Reynolds number, appear in the non-dimensional governing equations. When densimetric Froude similarity is satisfied, the analysis shows that the results would be scale-invariant for conservative density current under the rough turbulent condition. In the case of purely depositional flows, truly scale-invariant results cannot be obtained, as the Reynolds-mediated scale effects appear in the bottom boundary conditions of the flow velocity and sediment fall velocity. However, the scale effect would be relatively modest. The Reynolds effect becomes more significant for erosional or mixed erosional/depositional turbidity currents as Reynolds-mediated scale effects also appear in the sediment entrainment relation. Numerical simulations have been conducted at three different scales by considering densimetric Froude scaling alone as well as combined densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarity. Simulation results confirm that although the scaling of densimetric Froude number alone can produce scale-invariable results for conservative density currents, variations occur in the case of turbidity currents. The results become scale invariant when densimetric Froude and Reynolds similarities are satisfied simultaneously.

KW - Densimetric Froude number

KW - Froude number

KW - Numerical modeling

KW - Particle Reynolds number

KW - Reynolds number

KW - Scale effect

KW - Turbidity currents

KW - Turbulence modeling

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84992699674&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84992699674&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10652-016-9488-6

DO - 10.1007/s10652-016-9488-6

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84992699674

VL - 17

SP - 159

EP - 186

JO - Environmental Fluid Mechanics

JF - Environmental Fluid Mechanics

SN - 1567-7419

IS - 1

ER -