First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments: A meta-analysis

Sam E. Wortman, Ashley A. Holmes, Elizabeth Miernicki, Kaelyn Knoche, Cameron M. Pittelkow

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

Organic soil amendments are increasingly promoted as a sustainable alternative to synthetic fertilizers and as a tool for building soil quality through improved chemical, physical, and biological properties. However, short-term yield response to organic amendments is highly variable. A meta-analysis of 53 studies was conducted to (i) develop a global estimate of first-season crop yield response to organic amendments, and (ii) determine the effect of crop type, amendment characteristics, soil properties, cultural practices, and climate on the magnitude of this yield response. Yield response ratios were calculated (organic amendment yield compared to a non-fertilized control) and differences among groups were determined using 95% bootstrap confidence intervals (CI). Across all studies, crop yield increased 43±7% (95% CI) in the first-season after an organic amendment. Yield response was greatest for leafy crops (71±26% increase) and lowest for root/tuber/ bulb crops (29±10% increase). Poultry manure/compost was the most commonly used amendment and provided a yield increase of 76±21%. In contrast, plant-based amendments increased yield by only 27±9%. Amendment application rate alone was not an effective predictor of yield response, and there were not enough studies available to explore the possible interaction between amendment type and rate. Yield benefits of organic amendments were muted in soils with high organic matter and in arid climates. These results help identify options for maximizing the agronomic value of organic amendments, and suggest research is needed to improve agronomic efficiency of amendments in arid regions with poor soil quality.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1210-1217
Number of pages8
JournalAgronomy Journal
Volume109
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2017

Fingerprint

soil amendments
meta-analysis
organic soils
crop yield
arid zones
confidence interval
soil quality
crops
composted manure
poultry manure
plant cultural practices
bulbs
application rate
soil properties
tubers
soil organic matter
fertilizers
climate

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agronomy and Crop Science

Cite this

Wortman, S. E., Holmes, A. A., Miernicki, E., Knoche, K., & Pittelkow, C. M. (2017). First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments: A meta-analysis. Agronomy Journal, 109(4), 1210-1217. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627

First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments : A meta-analysis. / Wortman, Sam E.; Holmes, Ashley A.; Miernicki, Elizabeth; Knoche, Kaelyn; Pittelkow, Cameron M.

In: Agronomy Journal, Vol. 109, No. 4, 01.01.2017, p. 1210-1217.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Wortman, SE, Holmes, AA, Miernicki, E, Knoche, K & Pittelkow, CM 2017, 'First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments: A meta-analysis', Agronomy Journal, vol. 109, no. 4, pp. 1210-1217. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627
Wortman SE, Holmes AA, Miernicki E, Knoche K, Pittelkow CM. First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments: A meta-analysis. Agronomy Journal. 2017 Jan 1;109(4):1210-1217. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627
Wortman, Sam E. ; Holmes, Ashley A. ; Miernicki, Elizabeth ; Knoche, Kaelyn ; Pittelkow, Cameron M. / First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments : A meta-analysis. In: Agronomy Journal. 2017 ; Vol. 109, No. 4. pp. 1210-1217.
@article{4aebc91a46904553b445917e479afb13,
title = "First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments: A meta-analysis",
abstract = "Organic soil amendments are increasingly promoted as a sustainable alternative to synthetic fertilizers and as a tool for building soil quality through improved chemical, physical, and biological properties. However, short-term yield response to organic amendments is highly variable. A meta-analysis of 53 studies was conducted to (i) develop a global estimate of first-season crop yield response to organic amendments, and (ii) determine the effect of crop type, amendment characteristics, soil properties, cultural practices, and climate on the magnitude of this yield response. Yield response ratios were calculated (organic amendment yield compared to a non-fertilized control) and differences among groups were determined using 95{\%} bootstrap confidence intervals (CI). Across all studies, crop yield increased 43±7{\%} (95{\%} CI) in the first-season after an organic amendment. Yield response was greatest for leafy crops (71±26{\%} increase) and lowest for root/tuber/ bulb crops (29±10{\%} increase). Poultry manure/compost was the most commonly used amendment and provided a yield increase of 76±21{\%}. In contrast, plant-based amendments increased yield by only 27±9{\%}. Amendment application rate alone was not an effective predictor of yield response, and there were not enough studies available to explore the possible interaction between amendment type and rate. Yield benefits of organic amendments were muted in soils with high organic matter and in arid climates. These results help identify options for maximizing the agronomic value of organic amendments, and suggest research is needed to improve agronomic efficiency of amendments in arid regions with poor soil quality.",
author = "Wortman, {Sam E.} and Holmes, {Ashley A.} and Elizabeth Miernicki and Kaelyn Knoche and Pittelkow, {Cameron M.}",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "109",
pages = "1210--1217",
journal = "Agronomy Journal",
issn = "0002-1962",
publisher = "American Society of Agronomy",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - First-season crop yield response to organic soil amendments

T2 - A meta-analysis

AU - Wortman, Sam E.

AU - Holmes, Ashley A.

AU - Miernicki, Elizabeth

AU - Knoche, Kaelyn

AU - Pittelkow, Cameron M.

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Organic soil amendments are increasingly promoted as a sustainable alternative to synthetic fertilizers and as a tool for building soil quality through improved chemical, physical, and biological properties. However, short-term yield response to organic amendments is highly variable. A meta-analysis of 53 studies was conducted to (i) develop a global estimate of first-season crop yield response to organic amendments, and (ii) determine the effect of crop type, amendment characteristics, soil properties, cultural practices, and climate on the magnitude of this yield response. Yield response ratios were calculated (organic amendment yield compared to a non-fertilized control) and differences among groups were determined using 95% bootstrap confidence intervals (CI). Across all studies, crop yield increased 43±7% (95% CI) in the first-season after an organic amendment. Yield response was greatest for leafy crops (71±26% increase) and lowest for root/tuber/ bulb crops (29±10% increase). Poultry manure/compost was the most commonly used amendment and provided a yield increase of 76±21%. In contrast, plant-based amendments increased yield by only 27±9%. Amendment application rate alone was not an effective predictor of yield response, and there were not enough studies available to explore the possible interaction between amendment type and rate. Yield benefits of organic amendments were muted in soils with high organic matter and in arid climates. These results help identify options for maximizing the agronomic value of organic amendments, and suggest research is needed to improve agronomic efficiency of amendments in arid regions with poor soil quality.

AB - Organic soil amendments are increasingly promoted as a sustainable alternative to synthetic fertilizers and as a tool for building soil quality through improved chemical, physical, and biological properties. However, short-term yield response to organic amendments is highly variable. A meta-analysis of 53 studies was conducted to (i) develop a global estimate of first-season crop yield response to organic amendments, and (ii) determine the effect of crop type, amendment characteristics, soil properties, cultural practices, and climate on the magnitude of this yield response. Yield response ratios were calculated (organic amendment yield compared to a non-fertilized control) and differences among groups were determined using 95% bootstrap confidence intervals (CI). Across all studies, crop yield increased 43±7% (95% CI) in the first-season after an organic amendment. Yield response was greatest for leafy crops (71±26% increase) and lowest for root/tuber/ bulb crops (29±10% increase). Poultry manure/compost was the most commonly used amendment and provided a yield increase of 76±21%. In contrast, plant-based amendments increased yield by only 27±9%. Amendment application rate alone was not an effective predictor of yield response, and there were not enough studies available to explore the possible interaction between amendment type and rate. Yield benefits of organic amendments were muted in soils with high organic matter and in arid climates. These results help identify options for maximizing the agronomic value of organic amendments, and suggest research is needed to improve agronomic efficiency of amendments in arid regions with poor soil quality.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85023771455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85023771455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627

DO - 10.2134/agronj2016.10.0627

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85023771455

VL - 109

SP - 1210

EP - 1217

JO - Agronomy Journal

JF - Agronomy Journal

SN - 0002-1962

IS - 4

ER -