TY - JOUR
T1 - Energy and labor costs of alternative coal-electric fuel cycles
AU - Kurish, James
AU - Penner, Peter
AU - Hannon, Bruce
PY - 1981
Y1 - 1981
N2 - This report investigates the comparative net energy, job, and dollar costs of buying Western and Eastern coal in a fictitious Chicago power plant to produce 1000 kilowatt-hours of electricity. The energy and labor costs include all energy and labor required throughout the U. S. economy to produce this electricity. While this research was in progress, a law was passed requiring all new coal-fired power plants to scrub coal at 90 percent sulfur removal, whereas prior to this law, Western coal could be utilized without scrubbers. The dollar costs as well as the energy costs favored Western surface-mined coal versus Eastern coal whether underground or surface mined. For the purpose of trying to estimate the effects of the new law, data based on conventional limestone scrub of Western coal were used as well as a cycle with no scrubbing at all. When applying conventional scrubbers to Western coal, the least-cost energy and dollar cycle switches from the Western coal to the Eastern coal system. Obviously, transport distance plays a key role in this conclusion. The break-even distance at which transport energy equals the additional energy costs of conventional scrubbing was 2346 miles. When scrubbers are used on Eastern and Western coal, this break-even distance falls to 135 miles.
AB - This report investigates the comparative net energy, job, and dollar costs of buying Western and Eastern coal in a fictitious Chicago power plant to produce 1000 kilowatt-hours of electricity. The energy and labor costs include all energy and labor required throughout the U. S. economy to produce this electricity. While this research was in progress, a law was passed requiring all new coal-fired power plants to scrub coal at 90 percent sulfur removal, whereas prior to this law, Western coal could be utilized without scrubbers. The dollar costs as well as the energy costs favored Western surface-mined coal versus Eastern coal whether underground or surface mined. For the purpose of trying to estimate the effects of the new law, data based on conventional limestone scrub of Western coal were used as well as a cycle with no scrubbing at all. When applying conventional scrubbers to Western coal, the least-cost energy and dollar cycle switches from the Western coal to the Eastern coal system. Obviously, transport distance plays a key role in this conclusion. The break-even distance at which transport energy equals the additional energy costs of conventional scrubbing was 2346 miles. When scrubbers are used on Eastern and Western coal, this break-even distance falls to 135 miles.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0019662425&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0019662425&partnerID=8YFLogxK
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:0019662425
SN - 0090-8347
VL - 5
SP - 167
EP - 194
JO - Energy systems and policy
JF - Energy systems and policy
IS - 3
ER -