"E proboscis unum: Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty"

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

The phrase "e proboscis unum," a parody on the more familiar Latin phrase that means "out of many one" is taken from the courtroom scene of the 1964 Broadway musical Hello, Dolly! In this scene, the entire cast is under arrest for disturbing the peace, but the young impoverished clerk Cornelius Hackl takes the opportunity to proclaim his love for the milliner Irene Molloy in the song "It only takes a moment." The matchmaker Dolly pokes fun at the judge, the figure of authority, by commenting on the appearance of his nose, which she characterizes as "a flaming beacon of justice" and "living symbol of the motto of this great land," "e proboscis unum." The bickering, fighting crowd, however, in spite of the parody, are transformed into a community as they witness the young man's declaration. As this episode shows, popular culture reads the law and the courts as making possible a space for personal transformation and transformative sociality. The recent debate about same-sex marriage in Massachusetts shows that both individual persons and the law itself are open to a process of mutual transformation. The chapter uses Hello, Dolly!, the 2003 Massachusetts Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage, and Shoshana Felman's The Juridical Unconscious to argue that the study of law and literature is crucial in the current academic environment in which many critics, influenced by Giorgio Agamben, argue that law and the courts are merely the space for the exercise of the state's sovereign power to carry out punishment.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationLaw and Literature Reconsidered
EditorsAustin Sarat
Pages1-20
Number of pages20
DOIs
StatePublished - May 23 2008

Publication series

NameStudies in Law Politics and Society
Volume43
ISSN (Print)1059-4337

Fingerprint

sovereignty
love
Law
satire
marriage
sociality
court decision
popular culture
witness
song
Supreme Court
critic
penalty
symbol
peace
justice
human being
literature
community

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Sociology and Political Science
  • Political Science and International Relations
  • Law

Cite this

Murav, H. (2008). "E proboscis unum: Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty". In A. Sarat (Ed.), Law and Literature Reconsidered (pp. 1-20). (Studies in Law Politics and Society; Vol. 43). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1

"E proboscis unum : Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty". / Murav, Harriet.

Law and Literature Reconsidered. ed. / Austin Sarat. 2008. p. 1-20 (Studies in Law Politics and Society; Vol. 43).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Murav, H 2008, "E proboscis unum: Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty". in A Sarat (ed.), Law and Literature Reconsidered. Studies in Law Politics and Society, vol. 43, pp. 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1
Murav H. "E proboscis unum: Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty". In Sarat A, editor, Law and Literature Reconsidered. 2008. p. 1-20. (Studies in Law Politics and Society). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1
Murav, Harriet. / "E proboscis unum : Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty". Law and Literature Reconsidered. editor / Austin Sarat. 2008. pp. 1-20 (Studies in Law Politics and Society).
@inbook{638a4e114e1b4a13b5bf394d3f228a27,
title = "{"}E proboscis unum: Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty{"}",
abstract = "The phrase {"}e proboscis unum,{"} a parody on the more familiar Latin phrase that means {"}out of many one{"} is taken from the courtroom scene of the 1964 Broadway musical Hello, Dolly! In this scene, the entire cast is under arrest for disturbing the peace, but the young impoverished clerk Cornelius Hackl takes the opportunity to proclaim his love for the milliner Irene Molloy in the song {"}It only takes a moment.{"} The matchmaker Dolly pokes fun at the judge, the figure of authority, by commenting on the appearance of his nose, which she characterizes as {"}a flaming beacon of justice{"} and {"}living symbol of the motto of this great land,{"} {"}e proboscis unum.{"} The bickering, fighting crowd, however, in spite of the parody, are transformed into a community as they witness the young man's declaration. As this episode shows, popular culture reads the law and the courts as making possible a space for personal transformation and transformative sociality. The recent debate about same-sex marriage in Massachusetts shows that both individual persons and the law itself are open to a process of mutual transformation. The chapter uses Hello, Dolly!, the 2003 Massachusetts Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage, and Shoshana Felman's The Juridical Unconscious to argue that the study of law and literature is crucial in the current academic environment in which many critics, influenced by Giorgio Agamben, argue that law and the courts are merely the space for the exercise of the state's sovereign power to carry out punishment.",
author = "Harriet Murav",
year = "2008",
month = "5",
day = "23",
doi = "10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9780762314829",
series = "Studies in Law Politics and Society",
pages = "1--20",
editor = "Austin Sarat",
booktitle = "Law and Literature Reconsidered",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - "E proboscis unum

T2 - Law, literature, love, and the limits of sovereignty"

AU - Murav, Harriet

PY - 2008/5/23

Y1 - 2008/5/23

N2 - The phrase "e proboscis unum," a parody on the more familiar Latin phrase that means "out of many one" is taken from the courtroom scene of the 1964 Broadway musical Hello, Dolly! In this scene, the entire cast is under arrest for disturbing the peace, but the young impoverished clerk Cornelius Hackl takes the opportunity to proclaim his love for the milliner Irene Molloy in the song "It only takes a moment." The matchmaker Dolly pokes fun at the judge, the figure of authority, by commenting on the appearance of his nose, which she characterizes as "a flaming beacon of justice" and "living symbol of the motto of this great land," "e proboscis unum." The bickering, fighting crowd, however, in spite of the parody, are transformed into a community as they witness the young man's declaration. As this episode shows, popular culture reads the law and the courts as making possible a space for personal transformation and transformative sociality. The recent debate about same-sex marriage in Massachusetts shows that both individual persons and the law itself are open to a process of mutual transformation. The chapter uses Hello, Dolly!, the 2003 Massachusetts Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage, and Shoshana Felman's The Juridical Unconscious to argue that the study of law and literature is crucial in the current academic environment in which many critics, influenced by Giorgio Agamben, argue that law and the courts are merely the space for the exercise of the state's sovereign power to carry out punishment.

AB - The phrase "e proboscis unum," a parody on the more familiar Latin phrase that means "out of many one" is taken from the courtroom scene of the 1964 Broadway musical Hello, Dolly! In this scene, the entire cast is under arrest for disturbing the peace, but the young impoverished clerk Cornelius Hackl takes the opportunity to proclaim his love for the milliner Irene Molloy in the song "It only takes a moment." The matchmaker Dolly pokes fun at the judge, the figure of authority, by commenting on the appearance of his nose, which she characterizes as "a flaming beacon of justice" and "living symbol of the motto of this great land," "e proboscis unum." The bickering, fighting crowd, however, in spite of the parody, are transformed into a community as they witness the young man's declaration. As this episode shows, popular culture reads the law and the courts as making possible a space for personal transformation and transformative sociality. The recent debate about same-sex marriage in Massachusetts shows that both individual persons and the law itself are open to a process of mutual transformation. The chapter uses Hello, Dolly!, the 2003 Massachusetts Supreme Court decision on same-sex marriage, and Shoshana Felman's The Juridical Unconscious to argue that the study of law and literature is crucial in the current academic environment in which many critics, influenced by Giorgio Agamben, argue that law and the courts are merely the space for the exercise of the state's sovereign power to carry out punishment.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=43849097674&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=43849097674&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1

DO - 10.1016/S1059-4337(07)00601-1

M3 - Chapter

AN - SCOPUS:43849097674

SN - 9780762314829

T3 - Studies in Law Politics and Society

SP - 1

EP - 20

BT - Law and Literature Reconsidered

A2 - Sarat, Austin

ER -