Different explanations for surface and canopy urban heat island effects in relation to background climate

The background climatic conditions and urban morphology greatly influence urban heat island effects (UHIs), but one-size-fits-all solutions are frequently employed to mitigate UHIs. Here, attribution models for surface UHIs (SUHIs) and canopy UHIs (CUHIs) were developed to describe UHI formation. The contribution of factors to SUHIs and CUHIs shows similar dependencies on background climate and urban morphology. Furthermore, the factors that mainly contributed to CUHIs were more complex, and anthropogenic heat was the more critical factor. Influence from urban morphology also highlights that there is no one-size-fit-all solution for heat mitigation at the neighborhood. In particular, maintaining a low building density should be prioritized, especially mitigating CUHIs. Moreover, it is more effective to prioritize urban irrigation maintenance over increasing green cover in arid regions but the opposite in humid regions. The work can provide scientific evidence to support developing general and regional guidelines for urban heat mitigation.