Conceptualizing leakage and storage contributions from long open interval wells in regional deep basin flow models

Devin H. Mannix, Daniel Abrams, Daniel R. Hadley, George S Roadcap

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Deep basin aquifers are increasingly used in water-stressed areas, though their potential for sustainable development is inhibited by overlying aquitards and limited recharge rates. Long open interval wells (LOIWs)—wells uncased through multiple hydrostratigraphic units—are present in many confined aquifer systems and can be an important mechanism for deep basin aquifers to receive flow across aquitards. LOIWs are a major control on flow in the deep Cambrian–Ordovician sandstone aquifers of the upper Midwest, USA, providing a source of artificial leakage from shallow bedrock aquifers and equilibrating head within the sandstone aquifers despite differential pumpage. Conceptualizing and quantifying this anthropogenic flow has long been a challenge for groundwater flow modellers, particularly on a regional scale. Synoptic measurements of active production wells and well completion data for northeast Illinois form the basis for a transient, head-specified MODFLOW model that determines mass balance contributions to the region and estimates LOIW leakage to the aquifers. Using this insight, transient LOIW leakage was simulated using transiently changing K V zones in a traditional, Q-specified MODFLOW-USG model, a novel approach that allows the K V in a cell containing a LOIW to change transiently by use of the time-variant materials (TVM) package. With this modification, we achieved a consistent calibration through time, averaging 19.9 m root mean squared error. This model indicates that artificial leakage via LOIWs contributed a minimum of 10–13% of total flow to the sandstone aquifers through the entire history of pumping, up to 50% of flow around 1930. Removal from storage exceeds 40% of flow during peak withdrawals, much of this flow sourced from units other than the primary sandstone aquifers via LOIWs. As such, understanding the timing and magnitude of LOIW leakage is essential for predicting future water availability in deep basin aquifers.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)271-282
Number of pages12
JournalHydrological Processes
Volume33
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 15 2019

Fingerprint

leakage
well
aquifer
basin
sandstone
aquitard
well completion
confined aquifer
peak flow
water availability
groundwater flow
pumping
recharge
mass balance
bedrock
sustainable development
calibration
history

Keywords

  • MODFLOW
  • conceptual model
  • deep basin aquifer
  • groundwater
  • head-specified model
  • long open interval wells

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

Conceptualizing leakage and storage contributions from long open interval wells in regional deep basin flow models. / Mannix, Devin H.; Abrams, Daniel; Hadley, Daniel R.; Roadcap, George S.

In: Hydrological Processes, Vol. 33, No. 2, 15.01.2019, p. 271-282.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{4c99c5f2623d4a5991e3c6a6446ba404,
title = "Conceptualizing leakage and storage contributions from long open interval wells in regional deep basin flow models",
abstract = "Deep basin aquifers are increasingly used in water-stressed areas, though their potential for sustainable development is inhibited by overlying aquitards and limited recharge rates. Long open interval wells (LOIWs)—wells uncased through multiple hydrostratigraphic units—are present in many confined aquifer systems and can be an important mechanism for deep basin aquifers to receive flow across aquitards. LOIWs are a major control on flow in the deep Cambrian–Ordovician sandstone aquifers of the upper Midwest, USA, providing a source of artificial leakage from shallow bedrock aquifers and equilibrating head within the sandstone aquifers despite differential pumpage. Conceptualizing and quantifying this anthropogenic flow has long been a challenge for groundwater flow modellers, particularly on a regional scale. Synoptic measurements of active production wells and well completion data for northeast Illinois form the basis for a transient, head-specified MODFLOW model that determines mass balance contributions to the region and estimates LOIW leakage to the aquifers. Using this insight, transient LOIW leakage was simulated using transiently changing K V zones in a traditional, Q-specified MODFLOW-USG model, a novel approach that allows the K V in a cell containing a LOIW to change transiently by use of the time-variant materials (TVM) package. With this modification, we achieved a consistent calibration through time, averaging 19.9 m root mean squared error. This model indicates that artificial leakage via LOIWs contributed a minimum of 10–13{\%} of total flow to the sandstone aquifers through the entire history of pumping, up to 50{\%} of flow around 1930. Removal from storage exceeds 40{\%} of flow during peak withdrawals, much of this flow sourced from units other than the primary sandstone aquifers via LOIWs. As such, understanding the timing and magnitude of LOIW leakage is essential for predicting future water availability in deep basin aquifers.",
keywords = "MODFLOW, conceptual model, deep basin aquifer, groundwater, head-specified model, long open interval wells",
author = "Mannix, {Devin H.} and Daniel Abrams and Hadley, {Daniel R.} and Roadcap, {George S}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1002/hyp.13324",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "33",
pages = "271--282",
journal = "Hydrological Processes",
issn = "0885-6087",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conceptualizing leakage and storage contributions from long open interval wells in regional deep basin flow models

AU - Mannix, Devin H.

AU - Abrams, Daniel

AU - Hadley, Daniel R.

AU - Roadcap, George S

PY - 2019/1/15

Y1 - 2019/1/15

N2 - Deep basin aquifers are increasingly used in water-stressed areas, though their potential for sustainable development is inhibited by overlying aquitards and limited recharge rates. Long open interval wells (LOIWs)—wells uncased through multiple hydrostratigraphic units—are present in many confined aquifer systems and can be an important mechanism for deep basin aquifers to receive flow across aquitards. LOIWs are a major control on flow in the deep Cambrian–Ordovician sandstone aquifers of the upper Midwest, USA, providing a source of artificial leakage from shallow bedrock aquifers and equilibrating head within the sandstone aquifers despite differential pumpage. Conceptualizing and quantifying this anthropogenic flow has long been a challenge for groundwater flow modellers, particularly on a regional scale. Synoptic measurements of active production wells and well completion data for northeast Illinois form the basis for a transient, head-specified MODFLOW model that determines mass balance contributions to the region and estimates LOIW leakage to the aquifers. Using this insight, transient LOIW leakage was simulated using transiently changing K V zones in a traditional, Q-specified MODFLOW-USG model, a novel approach that allows the K V in a cell containing a LOIW to change transiently by use of the time-variant materials (TVM) package. With this modification, we achieved a consistent calibration through time, averaging 19.9 m root mean squared error. This model indicates that artificial leakage via LOIWs contributed a minimum of 10–13% of total flow to the sandstone aquifers through the entire history of pumping, up to 50% of flow around 1930. Removal from storage exceeds 40% of flow during peak withdrawals, much of this flow sourced from units other than the primary sandstone aquifers via LOIWs. As such, understanding the timing and magnitude of LOIW leakage is essential for predicting future water availability in deep basin aquifers.

AB - Deep basin aquifers are increasingly used in water-stressed areas, though their potential for sustainable development is inhibited by overlying aquitards and limited recharge rates. Long open interval wells (LOIWs)—wells uncased through multiple hydrostratigraphic units—are present in many confined aquifer systems and can be an important mechanism for deep basin aquifers to receive flow across aquitards. LOIWs are a major control on flow in the deep Cambrian–Ordovician sandstone aquifers of the upper Midwest, USA, providing a source of artificial leakage from shallow bedrock aquifers and equilibrating head within the sandstone aquifers despite differential pumpage. Conceptualizing and quantifying this anthropogenic flow has long been a challenge for groundwater flow modellers, particularly on a regional scale. Synoptic measurements of active production wells and well completion data for northeast Illinois form the basis for a transient, head-specified MODFLOW model that determines mass balance contributions to the region and estimates LOIW leakage to the aquifers. Using this insight, transient LOIW leakage was simulated using transiently changing K V zones in a traditional, Q-specified MODFLOW-USG model, a novel approach that allows the K V in a cell containing a LOIW to change transiently by use of the time-variant materials (TVM) package. With this modification, we achieved a consistent calibration through time, averaging 19.9 m root mean squared error. This model indicates that artificial leakage via LOIWs contributed a minimum of 10–13% of total flow to the sandstone aquifers through the entire history of pumping, up to 50% of flow around 1930. Removal from storage exceeds 40% of flow during peak withdrawals, much of this flow sourced from units other than the primary sandstone aquifers via LOIWs. As such, understanding the timing and magnitude of LOIW leakage is essential for predicting future water availability in deep basin aquifers.

KW - MODFLOW

KW - conceptual model

KW - deep basin aquifer

KW - groundwater

KW - head-specified model

KW - long open interval wells

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85057562114&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85057562114&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/hyp.13324

DO - 10.1002/hyp.13324

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85057562114

VL - 33

SP - 271

EP - 282

JO - Hydrological Processes

JF - Hydrological Processes

SN - 0885-6087

IS - 2

ER -