Challenging Geostatistical Methods To Represent Heterogeneity in CO2 Reservoirs Under Residual Trapping

James R Damico, Robert W. Ritzi, Naum I. Gershenzon, Roland T Okwen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Geostatistical methods based on two-point spatial-bivariate statistics have been used to model heterogeneity within computational studies of the dispersion of contaminants in groundwater reservoirs and the trapping of CO2 in geosequestration reservoirs. The ability of these methods to represent fluvial architecture, commonly occurring in such reservoirs, has been questioned. We challenged a widely used two-point spatial-bivariate statistical method to represent fluvial heterogeneity in the context of representing how reservoir heterogeneity affects residual trapping of CO2 injected for geosequestration. A more rigorous model for fluvial architecture was used as the benchmark in these studies. Both the geostatistically generated model and the benchmark model were interrogated, and metrics for the connectivity of high-permeability preferential flow pathways were quantified. Computational simulations of CO2 injection were performed, and metrics for CO2 dynamics and trapping were quantified. All metrics were similar between the two models. The percentage of high-permeability cells in spanning connected clusters (percolating clusters) was similar because percolation is strongly dependent upon proportions, and the same proportion of higher permeability cross-strata was specified in generating both models. The CO2 plume dynamics and residual trapping metrics were similar because they are largely controlled by the occurrence of percolating clusters. The benchmark model represented more features of the fluvial architecture and, depending on context, representing those features may be quite important, but the simpler geostatistical model was able to adequately represent fluvial reservoir architecture within the context and within the scope of the parameters represented here.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)357-373
Number of pages17
JournalEnvironmental and Engineering Geoscience
Volume24
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - 2018

Fingerprint

trapping
permeability
method
preferential flow
connectivity
Groundwater
Statistical methods
plume
Statistics
Impurities
groundwater
pollutant
simulation

Keywords

  • Capillary Trapping
  • Carbon Geosequestration
  • Geostatistics
  • Heterogeneity
  • Reservoir Engineering

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Engineering
  • Geotechnical Engineering and Engineering Geology
  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Challenging Geostatistical Methods To Represent Heterogeneity in CO2 Reservoirs Under Residual Trapping. / Damico, James R; Ritzi, Robert W.; Gershenzon, Naum I.; Okwen, Roland T.

In: Environmental and Engineering Geoscience, Vol. 24, No. 4, 2018, p. 357-373.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{be0189004f304f4ea988c89ef636fcaa,
title = "Challenging Geostatistical Methods To Represent Heterogeneity in CO2 Reservoirs Under Residual Trapping",
abstract = "Geostatistical methods based on two-point spatial-bivariate statistics have been used to model heterogeneity within computational studies of the dispersion of contaminants in groundwater reservoirs and the trapping of CO2 in geosequestration reservoirs. The ability of these methods to represent fluvial architecture, commonly occurring in such reservoirs, has been questioned. We challenged a widely used two-point spatial-bivariate statistical method to represent fluvial heterogeneity in the context of representing how reservoir heterogeneity affects residual trapping of CO2 injected for geosequestration. A more rigorous model for fluvial architecture was used as the benchmark in these studies. Both the geostatistically generated model and the benchmark model were interrogated, and metrics for the connectivity of high-permeability preferential flow pathways were quantified. Computational simulations of CO2 injection were performed, and metrics for CO2 dynamics and trapping were quantified. All metrics were similar between the two models. The percentage of high-permeability cells in spanning connected clusters (percolating clusters) was similar because percolation is strongly dependent upon proportions, and the same proportion of higher permeability cross-strata was specified in generating both models. The CO2 plume dynamics and residual trapping metrics were similar because they are largely controlled by the occurrence of percolating clusters. The benchmark model represented more features of the fluvial architecture and, depending on context, representing those features may be quite important, but the simpler geostatistical model was able to adequately represent fluvial reservoir architecture within the context and within the scope of the parameters represented here.",
keywords = "Capillary Trapping, Carbon Geosequestration, Geostatistics, Heterogeneity, Reservoir Engineering",
author = "Damico, {James R} and Ritzi, {Robert W.} and Gershenzon, {Naum I.} and Okwen, {Roland T}",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.2113/EEG-2116",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "357--373",
journal = "Environmental and Engineering Geoscience",
issn = "1078-7275",
publisher = "Geological Society of America",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Challenging Geostatistical Methods To Represent Heterogeneity in CO2 Reservoirs Under Residual Trapping

AU - Damico, James R

AU - Ritzi, Robert W.

AU - Gershenzon, Naum I.

AU - Okwen, Roland T

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Geostatistical methods based on two-point spatial-bivariate statistics have been used to model heterogeneity within computational studies of the dispersion of contaminants in groundwater reservoirs and the trapping of CO2 in geosequestration reservoirs. The ability of these methods to represent fluvial architecture, commonly occurring in such reservoirs, has been questioned. We challenged a widely used two-point spatial-bivariate statistical method to represent fluvial heterogeneity in the context of representing how reservoir heterogeneity affects residual trapping of CO2 injected for geosequestration. A more rigorous model for fluvial architecture was used as the benchmark in these studies. Both the geostatistically generated model and the benchmark model were interrogated, and metrics for the connectivity of high-permeability preferential flow pathways were quantified. Computational simulations of CO2 injection were performed, and metrics for CO2 dynamics and trapping were quantified. All metrics were similar between the two models. The percentage of high-permeability cells in spanning connected clusters (percolating clusters) was similar because percolation is strongly dependent upon proportions, and the same proportion of higher permeability cross-strata was specified in generating both models. The CO2 plume dynamics and residual trapping metrics were similar because they are largely controlled by the occurrence of percolating clusters. The benchmark model represented more features of the fluvial architecture and, depending on context, representing those features may be quite important, but the simpler geostatistical model was able to adequately represent fluvial reservoir architecture within the context and within the scope of the parameters represented here.

AB - Geostatistical methods based on two-point spatial-bivariate statistics have been used to model heterogeneity within computational studies of the dispersion of contaminants in groundwater reservoirs and the trapping of CO2 in geosequestration reservoirs. The ability of these methods to represent fluvial architecture, commonly occurring in such reservoirs, has been questioned. We challenged a widely used two-point spatial-bivariate statistical method to represent fluvial heterogeneity in the context of representing how reservoir heterogeneity affects residual trapping of CO2 injected for geosequestration. A more rigorous model for fluvial architecture was used as the benchmark in these studies. Both the geostatistically generated model and the benchmark model were interrogated, and metrics for the connectivity of high-permeability preferential flow pathways were quantified. Computational simulations of CO2 injection were performed, and metrics for CO2 dynamics and trapping were quantified. All metrics were similar between the two models. The percentage of high-permeability cells in spanning connected clusters (percolating clusters) was similar because percolation is strongly dependent upon proportions, and the same proportion of higher permeability cross-strata was specified in generating both models. The CO2 plume dynamics and residual trapping metrics were similar because they are largely controlled by the occurrence of percolating clusters. The benchmark model represented more features of the fluvial architecture and, depending on context, representing those features may be quite important, but the simpler geostatistical model was able to adequately represent fluvial reservoir architecture within the context and within the scope of the parameters represented here.

KW - Capillary Trapping

KW - Carbon Geosequestration

KW - Geostatistics

KW - Heterogeneity

KW - Reservoir Engineering

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068477278&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85068477278&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2113/EEG-2116

DO - 10.2113/EEG-2116

M3 - Article

VL - 24

SP - 357

EP - 373

JO - Environmental and Engineering Geoscience

JF - Environmental and Engineering Geoscience

SN - 1078-7275

IS - 4

ER -