TY - JOUR
T1 - Athena's Birth
T2 - Triggers, Actors, and Actions Preceding Industry Inception
AU - Agarwal, Rajshree
AU - Moeen, Mahka
AU - Shah, Sonali K.
N1 - Resolution of technological and demand uncertainty is also the focus of actions during the incubation stage. For technological uncertainty, while some missions need to extend available knowledge and technology bases, others require development of entire knowledge bases from scratch. These efforts typically involve coordinated research by firms and universities and extensive information exchange. For the case of penicillin, Fleming’s original discovery of penicillin in 1928 and the subsequent research by Howard Florey at the University of Oxford with the financial support of the Rockefeller Foundation provided an initial scientific base (Kingston, 2000). However, the treatment efficacy needed to be scientifically confirmed, and there were no production processes available for mass production. Collectively and through interactive experimentation, government agencies, universities, and firm collaborators found a solution. An important feature was that the firms involved received regular progress reports and agreed to freely exchange information about their findings (Klepper, 2016). In metal silos, with easily sourced technology from the developed countries, the creation of a well-functioning ecosystem within the Central American countries required attention to local needs. The SDC coordinated technology experimentation by tinsmiths and farmers during the incubation stage to address problems in the development of a viable supply chain and in optimal storage features that reduced harvest spoilage and pest control (Shah et al., 2017; Sonka et al., 2014). Within Sub-Saharan Africa, mission-driven coordination between nonprofit agencies such as the U.K. Department for International Development, diversifying entrants such as Vodafone, and entrepreneurial start-ups such as Safaricom and various independent agents addressed the technological and supply chain challenges for successful launch of M-Pesa as a mobile money platform. In contrast, within the same context, the inability to create win-win outcomes around the NFC (near field communication) chip standard for secure financial transactions between banks, credit card companies, and other intermediaries stifled inception of this industry (Ozcan & Santos, 2015). Similarly, in the absence of coordinated and collective efforts in the context of drugs for neglected diseases in poor countries, despite scattered basic scientific progress, a translation to clinical and commercial knowledge was largely unfruitful (Vakili & McGahan, 2016).
This paper is written in memory of our friend, colleague, and mentor: MB Sarkar. He passed far too early; we hope to continue our research with the same energy, dedication, and spirit of collaboration he devoted to his work. We thank the Kauffman Foundation for their funding and support of our research. We thank Serguey Braguinsky, Shane Greenstein, Michael Jacobides, Franco Malerba, Richard Nelson, Steven Sonka, and Sidney Winter for their thoughtful feedback. These ideas also benefitted from the comments of participants at the 2016 ICC Conference at UC-Berkeley and guidance from the editor, Gary Dushnitsky, and two reviewers. We also thank Hyeonsuh Lee for excellent research assistance.
DARPA refers to the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, an agency responsible for developing emerging technologies for use in the military. The internet project was initially funded and coordinated by the agency under its first name, Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA).
PY - 2017/9
Y1 - 2017/9
N2 - Research summary: Industry evolution scholars define industry inception as the first instance of product commercialization, focusing on subsequent time periods of growth and maturity. Left understudied are the triggers, actors, and actions preceding industry inception. We integrate recent research in a preliminary framework, conceptualizing the incubation stage as activated by a “trigger” event—a scientific discovery, unmet user need, or mission-oriented grand challenges—and continuing through the first instances of product commercialization. We focus on illuminating actions of multiple and heterogeneous actors that help reduce high technological and demand uncertainty, thereby shaping industry structure and strategic action post-commercialization. To point, although the actors may be different, their actions follow a similar theme. We hope this framework spurs future research investigating the understudied incubation stage of new industries. Managerial summary: Numerous visionaries––inventors, entrepreneurs, scientists, users, managers, policy makers, and others––spend decades laying the groundwork that leads to the creation of new industries. Their contributions are critical, yet have received little systematic attention. Here, we illuminate their actions during the understudied “incubation” stage sparked by a trigger event and culminating in the first instance of product commercialization. We begin by documenting three triggers: scientific and technological discoveries, unmet user needs, and mission-oriented grand challenges. We show that following a trigger event, visionaries solve the technological problems required to transform an innovative idea into a viable commercial product and engage potential adopters and stakeholders; they do this by both applying their existing knowledge base and engaging in experimentation. Their efforts set the stage for subsequent commercialization efforts.
AB - Research summary: Industry evolution scholars define industry inception as the first instance of product commercialization, focusing on subsequent time periods of growth and maturity. Left understudied are the triggers, actors, and actions preceding industry inception. We integrate recent research in a preliminary framework, conceptualizing the incubation stage as activated by a “trigger” event—a scientific discovery, unmet user need, or mission-oriented grand challenges—and continuing through the first instances of product commercialization. We focus on illuminating actions of multiple and heterogeneous actors that help reduce high technological and demand uncertainty, thereby shaping industry structure and strategic action post-commercialization. To point, although the actors may be different, their actions follow a similar theme. We hope this framework spurs future research investigating the understudied incubation stage of new industries. Managerial summary: Numerous visionaries––inventors, entrepreneurs, scientists, users, managers, policy makers, and others––spend decades laying the groundwork that leads to the creation of new industries. Their contributions are critical, yet have received little systematic attention. Here, we illuminate their actions during the understudied “incubation” stage sparked by a trigger event and culminating in the first instance of product commercialization. We begin by documenting three triggers: scientific and technological discoveries, unmet user needs, and mission-oriented grand challenges. We show that following a trigger event, visionaries solve the technological problems required to transform an innovative idea into a viable commercial product and engage potential adopters and stakeholders; they do this by both applying their existing knowledge base and engaging in experimentation. Their efforts set the stage for subsequent commercialization efforts.
KW - entrepreneurship
KW - industry evolution
KW - innovation
KW - knowledge
KW - nascent industries
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/85030165395
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/85030165395#tab=citedBy
U2 - 10.1002/sej.1259
DO - 10.1002/sej.1259
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85030165395
SN - 1932-4391
VL - 11
SP - 287
EP - 305
JO - Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal
JF - Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal
IS - 3
ER -