TY - JOUR
T1 - Are we projecting gender differences to ungendered things? Differences in referring to female versus male-named hurricanes based on 33 years of news coverage
AU - Dinh, Ly
AU - Sarol, M. Janina
AU - Jeoung, Sullam
AU - Diesner, Jana
N1 - This material is based upon work supported by the Cline Center for Advanced Social Research at UIUC, including a Linowes Fellowship. We appreciate the helpful feedback and continuous support of the Cline Center director, Dr. Scott Althaus. We also thank our Cline Center collaborators and domain experts in crisis communication, Dr. Sharon Shavitt and Dr. Kiju Jung. The authors also thank Jaehyun Park, Ke-Rou Wang, Dorothy Zhang, and Dr. Yi-Yun Cheng for their contributions to and dedicated efforts with the annotation and result validation.
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - Hurricanes are ungendered phenomena that are ascribed with gendered names. We examined if news information about the hurricanes is presented using gendered language. This work helps identify if people use gender stereotyping when referring to gender-neutral entities and what these stereotypes might be. We use methods from natural language processing, qualitative text analysis, and statistics to analyze how gender is expressed in disaster-related news via text-level indicators: (1) pronouns, (2) lexical, syntactic, and semantic features of words related to hurricanes, and (3) types of sources quoted. Our sample contains news articles on 47 hurricane events from 1979 to 2012, from two weeks before to two weeks after landfall. We find that: (1) hurricanes are mainly referred to by gender-neutral pronouns, however, (2) when gendered pronouns are used, female-named hurricanes are five times more likely to be referred to by a gendered pronoun than male-named hurricanes, (3) adjectives and verbs used in discussing female-named hurricanes are on average more negative than those used for reporting on male-named-hurricanes, and (4) governmental sources are most frequently quoted as authority voices (voices from citizens and non-governmental entities are catching up), and a majority of these voices do not directly mention hurricanes with gendered references.
AB - Hurricanes are ungendered phenomena that are ascribed with gendered names. We examined if news information about the hurricanes is presented using gendered language. This work helps identify if people use gender stereotyping when referring to gender-neutral entities and what these stereotypes might be. We use methods from natural language processing, qualitative text analysis, and statistics to analyze how gender is expressed in disaster-related news via text-level indicators: (1) pronouns, (2) lexical, syntactic, and semantic features of words related to hurricanes, and (3) types of sources quoted. Our sample contains news articles on 47 hurricane events from 1979 to 2012, from two weeks before to two weeks after landfall. We find that: (1) hurricanes are mainly referred to by gender-neutral pronouns, however, (2) when gendered pronouns are used, female-named hurricanes are five times more likely to be referred to by a gendered pronoun than male-named hurricanes, (3) adjectives and verbs used in discussing female-named hurricanes are on average more negative than those used for reporting on male-named-hurricanes, and (4) governmental sources are most frequently quoted as authority voices (voices from citizens and non-governmental entities are catching up), and a majority of these voices do not directly mention hurricanes with gendered references.
KW - crisis communication
KW - gender differences
KW - hurricanes
KW - natural language processing
KW - news reporting
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85166006201&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85166006201&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.5117/CCR2023.1.006.DINH
DO - 10.5117/CCR2023.1.006.DINH
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85166006201
SN - 2665-9085
VL - 5
SP - 141
EP - 180
JO - Computational Communication Research
JF - Computational Communication Research
IS - 1
ER -