Architecting waferscale processors-A GPU case study

Increasing communication overheads are already threatening computer system scaling. One approach to dramatically reduce communication overheads is waferscale processing. However, waferscale processors [1], [2], [3] have been historically deemed impractical due to yield issues [1], [4] inherent to conventional integration technology. Emerging integration technologies such as Silicon-Interconnection Fabric (Si-IF) [5], [6], [7], where pre-manufactured dies are directly bonded on to a silicon wafer, may enable one to build a waferscale system without the corresponding yield issues. As such, waferscalar architectures need to be revisited. In this paper, we study if it is feasible and useful to build today's architectures at waferscale. Using a waferscale GPU as a case study, we show that while a 300 mm wafer can house about 100 GPU modules (GPM), only a much scaled down GPU architecture with about 40 GPMs can be built when physical concerns are considered. We also study the performance and energy implications of waferscale architectures. We show that waferscale GPUs can provide significant performance and energy efficiency advantages (up to 18.9x speedup and 143x EDP benefit compared against equivalent MCM-GPU based implementation on PCB) without any change in the programming model. We also develop thread scheduling and data placement policies for waferscale GPU architectures. Our policies outperform state-of-art scheduling and data placement policies by up to 2.88x (average 1.4x) and 1.62x (average 1.11x) for 24 GPM and 40 GPM cases respectively. Finally, we build the first Si-IF prototype with interconnected dies. We observe 100% of the inter-die interconnects to be successfully connected in our prototype. Coupled with the high yield reported previously for bonding of dies on Si-IF, this demonstrates the technological readiness for building a waferscale GPU architecture.