Accounting Reporting Complexity and Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure

Nerissa C. Brown, Shira Cohen, Adrienna A. Huffman

Research output: Working paper

Abstract

The continuing proliferation of non-GAAP (or adjusted) earnings measures in corporate disclosures has led accounting standard-setters and financial reporting regulators to debate whether this disclosure trend is in response to the increasing complexity of GAAP accounting. We inform this debate by investigating the role of accounting-based complexity in shaping the disclosure and quality of manager-adjusted earnings information. Using a firm-level XBRL measure of accounting reporting complexity that links directly to the FASB codification, we find that managers’ propensity to disclose non-GAAP earnings information increases with the firm’s accounting complexity as reported in the financial statement filing. Notably, the effect of accounting complexity on non-GAAP disclosure is robust to, and distinct from, the effects arising from operational complexity and the linguistic complexity of the financial report. Our results also indicate that non-GAAP disclosure is particularly sensitive to the reporting complexity of firms’ income and cash flow performance as well as the complexity of authoritative accounting principles. Furthermore, we find that the earnings items managers exclude when deriving the non-GAAP figure are of higher quality when accounting disclosures are complex, though the complexity inherent in certain accounts seem to lead some managers to (un)intentionally make low-quality earnings adjustments. Taken together, our evidence suggests that non-GAAP reporting practices are in part a strategic response to the complexity of accounting principles.
Original languageEnglish (US)
Number of pages55
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 14 2018

Fingerprint

Disclosure
Managers
Accounting principles
Accounting disclosure
Accounting firms
Financial statements
Cash flow
Financial reporting
Proliferation
Codification
Accounting standards
Corporate disclosure
Propensity
Strategic response
Earnings quality
Income

Keywords

  • non-GAAP earnings
  • accounting complexity
  • XBRL

Cite this

Accounting Reporting Complexity and Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure. / Brown, Nerissa C.; Cohen, Shira; Huffman, Adrienna A.

2018.

Research output: Working paper

@techreport{e9352221a7484caf8713a06dc1b21c11,
title = "Accounting Reporting Complexity and Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure",
abstract = "The continuing proliferation of non-GAAP (or adjusted) earnings measures in corporate disclosures has led accounting standard-setters and financial reporting regulators to debate whether this disclosure trend is in response to the increasing complexity of GAAP accounting. We inform this debate by investigating the role of accounting-based complexity in shaping the disclosure and quality of manager-adjusted earnings information. Using a firm-level XBRL measure of accounting reporting complexity that links directly to the FASB codification, we find that managers’ propensity to disclose non-GAAP earnings information increases with the firm’s accounting complexity as reported in the financial statement filing. Notably, the effect of accounting complexity on non-GAAP disclosure is robust to, and distinct from, the effects arising from operational complexity and the linguistic complexity of the financial report. Our results also indicate that non-GAAP disclosure is particularly sensitive to the reporting complexity of firms’ income and cash flow performance as well as the complexity of authoritative accounting principles. Furthermore, we find that the earnings items managers exclude when deriving the non-GAAP figure are of higher quality when accounting disclosures are complex, though the complexity inherent in certain accounts seem to lead some managers to (un)intentionally make low-quality earnings adjustments. Taken together, our evidence suggests that non-GAAP reporting practices are in part a strategic response to the complexity of accounting principles.",
keywords = "non-GAAP earnings, accounting complexity, XBRL",
author = "Brown, {Nerissa C.} and Shira Cohen and Huffman, {Adrienna A.}",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "14",
doi = "10.2139/ssrn.3242021",
language = "English (US)",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - Accounting Reporting Complexity and Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure

AU - Brown, Nerissa C.

AU - Cohen, Shira

AU - Huffman, Adrienna A.

PY - 2018/9/14

Y1 - 2018/9/14

N2 - The continuing proliferation of non-GAAP (or adjusted) earnings measures in corporate disclosures has led accounting standard-setters and financial reporting regulators to debate whether this disclosure trend is in response to the increasing complexity of GAAP accounting. We inform this debate by investigating the role of accounting-based complexity in shaping the disclosure and quality of manager-adjusted earnings information. Using a firm-level XBRL measure of accounting reporting complexity that links directly to the FASB codification, we find that managers’ propensity to disclose non-GAAP earnings information increases with the firm’s accounting complexity as reported in the financial statement filing. Notably, the effect of accounting complexity on non-GAAP disclosure is robust to, and distinct from, the effects arising from operational complexity and the linguistic complexity of the financial report. Our results also indicate that non-GAAP disclosure is particularly sensitive to the reporting complexity of firms’ income and cash flow performance as well as the complexity of authoritative accounting principles. Furthermore, we find that the earnings items managers exclude when deriving the non-GAAP figure are of higher quality when accounting disclosures are complex, though the complexity inherent in certain accounts seem to lead some managers to (un)intentionally make low-quality earnings adjustments. Taken together, our evidence suggests that non-GAAP reporting practices are in part a strategic response to the complexity of accounting principles.

AB - The continuing proliferation of non-GAAP (or adjusted) earnings measures in corporate disclosures has led accounting standard-setters and financial reporting regulators to debate whether this disclosure trend is in response to the increasing complexity of GAAP accounting. We inform this debate by investigating the role of accounting-based complexity in shaping the disclosure and quality of manager-adjusted earnings information. Using a firm-level XBRL measure of accounting reporting complexity that links directly to the FASB codification, we find that managers’ propensity to disclose non-GAAP earnings information increases with the firm’s accounting complexity as reported in the financial statement filing. Notably, the effect of accounting complexity on non-GAAP disclosure is robust to, and distinct from, the effects arising from operational complexity and the linguistic complexity of the financial report. Our results also indicate that non-GAAP disclosure is particularly sensitive to the reporting complexity of firms’ income and cash flow performance as well as the complexity of authoritative accounting principles. Furthermore, we find that the earnings items managers exclude when deriving the non-GAAP figure are of higher quality when accounting disclosures are complex, though the complexity inherent in certain accounts seem to lead some managers to (un)intentionally make low-quality earnings adjustments. Taken together, our evidence suggests that non-GAAP reporting practices are in part a strategic response to the complexity of accounting principles.

KW - non-GAAP earnings

KW - accounting complexity

KW - XBRL

U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.3242021

DO - 10.2139/ssrn.3242021

M3 - Working paper

BT - Accounting Reporting Complexity and Non-GAAP Earnings Disclosure

ER -