A sense of belonging

Writing (righting) inclusion and equity in a child's transition to school

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Literacy studies with a sociocultural and participatory view of learning must confront the issue of institutional belonging. Without a sense of inclusion, there are no relationships within which literacy learning can unfold. In this article, I probe this sense from the vantage point of a small Black child as he transitions from a preschool program serving primarily low-income children of color to a kindergarten in a predominantly White, middle-class area. This ethnographic case study is based on four months of observation in the last half of the preschool year (focused on the child's participation in classroom composing practices) and five months of observation in the beginning of kindergarten (with similar focus). The analysis centered, first, on the child's situated encounters with other children that could mark him as out of place. The child faced varied kinds of challenges linked to intersecting societal forces, including race, class, gender, and notions of writing competence itself. Second, the analysis considered the contradictory roles of written language in the negotiation of inclusion. Literacy test results situated him outside the classroom "norm"; literacy as a symbolic and communicative tool situated him as an active social negotiator. The case reveals the flimsiness of the ladder of literacy skills as a way of understanding a child's school experiences and the importance of critically aware teachers who help children construct common ground upon which they all belong as learners, players, and peers.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)236-261
Number of pages26
JournalResearch in the Teaching of English
Volume52
Issue number3
StatePublished - Feb 1 2018

Fingerprint

equity
inclusion
literacy
school
kindergarten
classroom
Inclusion
Equity
written language
learning
middle class
low income
participation
gender
teacher
Literacy
experience
Kindergarten

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Language and Linguistics
  • Education
  • Linguistics and Language

Cite this

A sense of belonging : Writing (righting) inclusion and equity in a child's transition to school. / Dyson, Anne Haas.

In: Research in the Teaching of English, Vol. 52, No. 3, 01.02.2018, p. 236-261.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1bf0fbe827b946ada3c476bb27cca0e3,
title = "A sense of belonging: Writing (righting) inclusion and equity in a child's transition to school",
abstract = "Literacy studies with a sociocultural and participatory view of learning must confront the issue of institutional belonging. Without a sense of inclusion, there are no relationships within which literacy learning can unfold. In this article, I probe this sense from the vantage point of a small Black child as he transitions from a preschool program serving primarily low-income children of color to a kindergarten in a predominantly White, middle-class area. This ethnographic case study is based on four months of observation in the last half of the preschool year (focused on the child's participation in classroom composing practices) and five months of observation in the beginning of kindergarten (with similar focus). The analysis centered, first, on the child's situated encounters with other children that could mark him as out of place. The child faced varied kinds of challenges linked to intersecting societal forces, including race, class, gender, and notions of writing competence itself. Second, the analysis considered the contradictory roles of written language in the negotiation of inclusion. Literacy test results situated him outside the classroom {"}norm{"}; literacy as a symbolic and communicative tool situated him as an active social negotiator. The case reveals the flimsiness of the ladder of literacy skills as a way of understanding a child's school experiences and the importance of critically aware teachers who help children construct common ground upon which they all belong as learners, players, and peers.",
author = "Dyson, {Anne Haas}",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "52",
pages = "236--261",
journal = "Research in the Teaching of English",
issn = "0034-527X",
publisher = "National Council of Teachers of English",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A sense of belonging

T2 - Writing (righting) inclusion and equity in a child's transition to school

AU - Dyson, Anne Haas

PY - 2018/2/1

Y1 - 2018/2/1

N2 - Literacy studies with a sociocultural and participatory view of learning must confront the issue of institutional belonging. Without a sense of inclusion, there are no relationships within which literacy learning can unfold. In this article, I probe this sense from the vantage point of a small Black child as he transitions from a preschool program serving primarily low-income children of color to a kindergarten in a predominantly White, middle-class area. This ethnographic case study is based on four months of observation in the last half of the preschool year (focused on the child's participation in classroom composing practices) and five months of observation in the beginning of kindergarten (with similar focus). The analysis centered, first, on the child's situated encounters with other children that could mark him as out of place. The child faced varied kinds of challenges linked to intersecting societal forces, including race, class, gender, and notions of writing competence itself. Second, the analysis considered the contradictory roles of written language in the negotiation of inclusion. Literacy test results situated him outside the classroom "norm"; literacy as a symbolic and communicative tool situated him as an active social negotiator. The case reveals the flimsiness of the ladder of literacy skills as a way of understanding a child's school experiences and the importance of critically aware teachers who help children construct common ground upon which they all belong as learners, players, and peers.

AB - Literacy studies with a sociocultural and participatory view of learning must confront the issue of institutional belonging. Without a sense of inclusion, there are no relationships within which literacy learning can unfold. In this article, I probe this sense from the vantage point of a small Black child as he transitions from a preschool program serving primarily low-income children of color to a kindergarten in a predominantly White, middle-class area. This ethnographic case study is based on four months of observation in the last half of the preschool year (focused on the child's participation in classroom composing practices) and five months of observation in the beginning of kindergarten (with similar focus). The analysis centered, first, on the child's situated encounters with other children that could mark him as out of place. The child faced varied kinds of challenges linked to intersecting societal forces, including race, class, gender, and notions of writing competence itself. Second, the analysis considered the contradictory roles of written language in the negotiation of inclusion. Literacy test results situated him outside the classroom "norm"; literacy as a symbolic and communicative tool situated him as an active social negotiator. The case reveals the flimsiness of the ladder of literacy skills as a way of understanding a child's school experiences and the importance of critically aware teachers who help children construct common ground upon which they all belong as learners, players, and peers.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85042144238&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85042144238&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 52

SP - 236

EP - 261

JO - Research in the Teaching of English

JF - Research in the Teaching of English

SN - 0034-527X

IS - 3

ER -