A DFT and ab Initio benchmarking study of metal-Alkane interactions and the activation of carbon-hydrogen bonds

Charity Flener-Lovitt, David E. Woon, Thom H. Dunning, Gregory S. Girolami

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Density functional theory and ab initio methods have been used to calculate the structures and energies of minima and transition states for the reactions of methane coordinated to a transition metal. The reactions studied are reversible C-H bond activation of the coordinated methane ligand to form a transition metal methyl hydride complex and dissociation of the coordinated methane ligand. The reaction sequence can be summarized as L xM(CH3)H ⇄ LxM(CH4) ⇄ LxM + CH4, where LxM is the osmium-containing fragment (C5H5)Os(R2PCH2PR 2)+ and R is H or CH3. Three-center metal-carbon-hydrogen interactions play an important role in this system. Both basis sets and functional have been benchmarked in this work, including new correlation consistent basis sets for a third transition series element, osmium. Double zeta quality correlation consistent basis sets yield energies close to those from calculations with quadruple-ζ basis sets, with variations that are smaller than the differences between functionals. The energies of important species on the potential energy surface, calculated by using 10 DFT functionals, are compared both to experimental values and to CCSD(T) single point calculations. Kohn-Sham natural bond orbital descriptions are used to understand the differences between functionals. Older functionals favor electrostatic interactions over weak donor-acceptor interactions and, therefore, are not particularly well suited for describing systems-such as σ-complexes-in which the latter are dominant. Newer kinetic and dispersion-corrected functionals such as MPWlK and M052X provide significantly better descriptions of the bonding interactions, as judged by their ability to predict energies closer to CCSD(T) values. Kohn-Sham and natural bond orbitais are used to differentiate between bonding descriptions. Our evaluations of these basis sets and DFT functionals lead us to recommend the use of dispersion corrected functionals in conjunction with double-ζ," or larger basis sets with polarization functions for calculations involving weak interactions, such as those found in σ-complexes with transition metals.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1843-1851
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Physical Chemistry A
Volume114
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2010

Fingerprint

Alkanes
Methane
Benchmarking
Discrete Fourier transforms
functionals
alkanes
Transition metals
Osmium
Hydrogen bonds
Carbon
Metals
Chemical activation
activation
hydrogen bonds
carbon
metals
Ligands
Potential energy surfaces
interactions
Coulomb interactions

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physical and Theoretical Chemistry

Cite this

A DFT and ab Initio benchmarking study of metal-Alkane interactions and the activation of carbon-hydrogen bonds. / Flener-Lovitt, Charity; Woon, David E.; Dunning, Thom H.; Girolami, Gregory S.

In: Journal of Physical Chemistry A, Vol. 114, No. 4, 01.03.2010, p. 1843-1851.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{264bc3baaad747eb9ac2723fb70683cb,
title = "A DFT and ab Initio benchmarking study of metal-Alkane interactions and the activation of carbon-hydrogen bonds",
abstract = "Density functional theory and ab initio methods have been used to calculate the structures and energies of minima and transition states for the reactions of methane coordinated to a transition metal. The reactions studied are reversible C-H bond activation of the coordinated methane ligand to form a transition metal methyl hydride complex and dissociation of the coordinated methane ligand. The reaction sequence can be summarized as L xM(CH3)H ⇄ LxM(CH4) ⇄ LxM + CH4, where LxM is the osmium-containing fragment (C5H5)Os(R2PCH2PR 2)+ and R is H or CH3. Three-center metal-carbon-hydrogen interactions play an important role in this system. Both basis sets and functional have been benchmarked in this work, including new correlation consistent basis sets for a third transition series element, osmium. Double zeta quality correlation consistent basis sets yield energies close to those from calculations with quadruple-ζ basis sets, with variations that are smaller than the differences between functionals. The energies of important species on the potential energy surface, calculated by using 10 DFT functionals, are compared both to experimental values and to CCSD(T) single point calculations. Kohn-Sham natural bond orbital descriptions are used to understand the differences between functionals. Older functionals favor electrostatic interactions over weak donor-acceptor interactions and, therefore, are not particularly well suited for describing systems-such as σ-complexes-in which the latter are dominant. Newer kinetic and dispersion-corrected functionals such as MPWlK and M052X provide significantly better descriptions of the bonding interactions, as judged by their ability to predict energies closer to CCSD(T) values. Kohn-Sham and natural bond orbitais are used to differentiate between bonding descriptions. Our evaluations of these basis sets and DFT functionals lead us to recommend the use of dispersion corrected functionals in conjunction with double-ζ,{"} or larger basis sets with polarization functions for calculations involving weak interactions, such as those found in σ-complexes with transition metals.",
author = "Charity Flener-Lovitt and Woon, {David E.} and Dunning, {Thom H.} and Girolami, {Gregory S.}",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1021/jp9058033",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "114",
pages = "1843--1851",
journal = "Journal of Physical Chemistry A",
issn = "1089-5639",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A DFT and ab Initio benchmarking study of metal-Alkane interactions and the activation of carbon-hydrogen bonds

AU - Flener-Lovitt, Charity

AU - Woon, David E.

AU - Dunning, Thom H.

AU - Girolami, Gregory S.

PY - 2010/3/1

Y1 - 2010/3/1

N2 - Density functional theory and ab initio methods have been used to calculate the structures and energies of minima and transition states for the reactions of methane coordinated to a transition metal. The reactions studied are reversible C-H bond activation of the coordinated methane ligand to form a transition metal methyl hydride complex and dissociation of the coordinated methane ligand. The reaction sequence can be summarized as L xM(CH3)H ⇄ LxM(CH4) ⇄ LxM + CH4, where LxM is the osmium-containing fragment (C5H5)Os(R2PCH2PR 2)+ and R is H or CH3. Three-center metal-carbon-hydrogen interactions play an important role in this system. Both basis sets and functional have been benchmarked in this work, including new correlation consistent basis sets for a third transition series element, osmium. Double zeta quality correlation consistent basis sets yield energies close to those from calculations with quadruple-ζ basis sets, with variations that are smaller than the differences between functionals. The energies of important species on the potential energy surface, calculated by using 10 DFT functionals, are compared both to experimental values and to CCSD(T) single point calculations. Kohn-Sham natural bond orbital descriptions are used to understand the differences between functionals. Older functionals favor electrostatic interactions over weak donor-acceptor interactions and, therefore, are not particularly well suited for describing systems-such as σ-complexes-in which the latter are dominant. Newer kinetic and dispersion-corrected functionals such as MPWlK and M052X provide significantly better descriptions of the bonding interactions, as judged by their ability to predict energies closer to CCSD(T) values. Kohn-Sham and natural bond orbitais are used to differentiate between bonding descriptions. Our evaluations of these basis sets and DFT functionals lead us to recommend the use of dispersion corrected functionals in conjunction with double-ζ," or larger basis sets with polarization functions for calculations involving weak interactions, such as those found in σ-complexes with transition metals.

AB - Density functional theory and ab initio methods have been used to calculate the structures and energies of minima and transition states for the reactions of methane coordinated to a transition metal. The reactions studied are reversible C-H bond activation of the coordinated methane ligand to form a transition metal methyl hydride complex and dissociation of the coordinated methane ligand. The reaction sequence can be summarized as L xM(CH3)H ⇄ LxM(CH4) ⇄ LxM + CH4, where LxM is the osmium-containing fragment (C5H5)Os(R2PCH2PR 2)+ and R is H or CH3. Three-center metal-carbon-hydrogen interactions play an important role in this system. Both basis sets and functional have been benchmarked in this work, including new correlation consistent basis sets for a third transition series element, osmium. Double zeta quality correlation consistent basis sets yield energies close to those from calculations with quadruple-ζ basis sets, with variations that are smaller than the differences between functionals. The energies of important species on the potential energy surface, calculated by using 10 DFT functionals, are compared both to experimental values and to CCSD(T) single point calculations. Kohn-Sham natural bond orbital descriptions are used to understand the differences between functionals. Older functionals favor electrostatic interactions over weak donor-acceptor interactions and, therefore, are not particularly well suited for describing systems-such as σ-complexes-in which the latter are dominant. Newer kinetic and dispersion-corrected functionals such as MPWlK and M052X provide significantly better descriptions of the bonding interactions, as judged by their ability to predict energies closer to CCSD(T) values. Kohn-Sham and natural bond orbitais are used to differentiate between bonding descriptions. Our evaluations of these basis sets and DFT functionals lead us to recommend the use of dispersion corrected functionals in conjunction with double-ζ," or larger basis sets with polarization functions for calculations involving weak interactions, such as those found in σ-complexes with transition metals.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77249147868&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77249147868&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/jp9058033

DO - 10.1021/jp9058033

M3 - Article

C2 - 20043689

AN - SCOPUS:77249147868

VL - 114

SP - 1843

EP - 1851

JO - Journal of Physical Chemistry A

JF - Journal of Physical Chemistry A

SN - 1089-5639

IS - 4

ER -