Second-generation citation context analysis (2010-2019) to retracted paper Matsuyama 2005

Dataset

Description

Citation context annotation. This is part of the supplemental data for Jodi Schneider, Di Ye, Alison Hill, and Ashley Whitehorn. "Continued Citation of a Fraudulent Clinical Trial Report, Eleven Years after it was retracted for Falsifying Data" [R&R under review with Scientometrics].

Publications were selected by examining all citations to the retracted paper Matsuyama 2005, and selecting the 35 citing papers, published 2010 to 2019, which do not mention the retraction, but which mention the methods or results of the retracted paper (called "specific" in Ye, Di; Hill, Alison; Whitehorn (Fulton), Ashley; Schneider, Jodi (2020): Citation context annotation for new and newly found citations (2006-2019) to retracted paper Matsuyama 2005. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. <a href="https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-8150563_V1">https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-8150563_V1</a> ). The annotated citations are second-generation citations to the retracted paper Matsuyama 2005 (RETRACTED: Matsuyama W, Mitsuyama H, Watanabe M, Oonakahara KI, Higashimoto I, Osame M, Arimura K. Effects of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids on inflammatory markers in COPD. Chest. 2005 Dec 1;128(6):3817-27.), retracted in 2008 (Retraction in: Chest (2008) 134:4 (893) <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-3692(08)60339-6">https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-3692(08)60339-6<a/> ).


FILES/FILE FORMATS
Same data in two formats:
2010-2019 SG to specific not mentioned FG.csv - Unicode CSV (preservation format only)
2010-2019 SG to specific not mentioned FG.xlsx - Excel workbook (preferred format)

ABBREVIATIONS:
2G - Refers to the second-generation of Matusyama
FG - Refers to the direct citation of Matsuyama (the one the second-generation item cites)

ROW EXPLANATIONS
161 rows - one second-generation citation per row

COLUMN HEADER EXPLANATIONS

Note - processing notes and other comments

No access - "No access" if not available, blank otherwise

Annotation pending - "Y" if pending, otherwise blank

2G article - ID for the second-generation item. Corresponds to the network analysis. See Ye, Di; Schneider, Jodi (2019): Network of First and Second-generation citations to Matsuyama 2005 from Google
Scholar and Web of Science. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. <a href="https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2">https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2</a>

2G Title - title for the second-generation item (some have non-Latin characters, commas, etc.)

2G Officially translated title - item title in English, as listed in the publication, for the second-generation item (some have commas, etc.)

2G Automatically translated title - item title in English, translated by Google Scholar, for the second-generation item (some have commas, etc.)

2G Author - author for the second-generation item (abbreviated, mostly sourced from Google Scholar, and not data cleaned)

2G Year - publication year for the second-generation item

2G URL - URL for the second-generation item

2G type - publication type for the second-generation item (e.g., bachelor's thesis, blog post, book chapter, clinical guidelines, Cochrane Review, consumer-oriented evidence summary, continuing education journal article, journal article, letter to the editor, magazine article, Master's thesis, patent, Ph.D. thesis, textbook chapter, training module)

2G is also FG - "Yes" if the item is also a direct citation to Matsuyama (NOTE: if so, lacks S in ID)

2G that is FG acknowledges Matsuyama's retraction - "Y" if this is a first-generation AND second-generation citation which acknowledges the retraction

FG in bibliography - ID for the item cited by the second-generation item. Corresponds to the network analysis. See Ye, Di; Schneider, Jodi (2019): Network of First and Second-generation citations to Matsuyama 2005 from Google
Scholar and Web of Science. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. <a href="https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2">https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2</a>

FG Officially translated title - item title in English, as listed in the publication, for cited item.

FG Title - title for the cited item (some have non-Latin characters, commas, etc.)

FG Author - author for the cited item (abbreviated, mostly sourced from Google Scholar, and not completely data cleaned)

FG Year - publication year for the cited item

Reference number/style of FG in 2G - number or string used in the text to stand for the cited item

2G Language - publication language of the second-generation item

Review possible impact overall? "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper - aggregates Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation X)

Quotation 1 - First quotation (or blank) (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 1 - English translation of "Quotation 1" (or blank), from Google Scholar

Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation 1) - "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper Quotation 1

Quotation 2 - Second quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 2 - English translation of "Quotation 2", from Google Scholar

Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation 2) - "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper based on Quotation 2

Quotation 3 - Third quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 3 - English translation of "Quotation 3", from Google Scholar

Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation 3) - "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper based on Quotation 3

Quotation 4 - Fourth quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 4 - English translation of "Quotation 4", from Google Scholar

Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation 4) - "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper based on Quotation 4

Quotation 5 - Fifth quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 5 - English translation of "Quotation 5", from Google Scholar

Use of Matsuyama info/Possible impact (Quotation 5) - "Y" or "N" (blank if not annotated) - refers to perceived potential to spread misinformation from the Matsuyama paper based on Quotation 5
Date made availableFeb 23 2020
PublisherUniversity of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Keywords

  • second-generation citation context analysis
  • citation context annotation
  • retraction
  • diffusion of retraction

Cite this

Schneider, J. A. (Creator), Ye, D. (Creator) (Feb 23 2020). Second-generation citation context analysis (2010-2019) to retracted paper Matsuyama 2005. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. 10.13012/B2IDB-3331845_V1