Citation context annotation for new and newly found citations (2006-2019) to retracted paper Matsuyama 2005

  • Di Ye (Creator)
  • Alison Hill (Creator)
  • Ashley Whitehorn (Fulton) (Creator)
  • Jodi Schneider (Creator)

Dataset

Description

Citation context annotation for papers citing retracted paper Matsuyama 2005 (RETRACTED: Matsuyama W, Mitsuyama H, Watanabe M, Oonakahara KI, Higashimoto I, Osame M, Arimura K. Effects of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids on inflammatory markers in COPD. Chest. 2005 Dec 1;128(6):3817-27.), retracted in 2008 (Retraction in: Chest (2008) 134:4 (893) <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-3692(08)60339-6">https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-3692(08)60339-6<a/> ). This is part of the supplemental data for Jodi Schneider, Di Ye, Alison Hill, and Ashley Whitehorn. "Continued Citation of a Fraudulent Clinical Trial Report, Eleven Years after it was retracted for Falsifying Data" [R&R under review with Scientometrics].

Overall we found 148 citations to the retracted paper from 2006 to 2019, However, this dataset does not include the annotations described in the 2015. in Ashley Fulton, Alison Coates, Marie Williams, Peter Howe, and Alison Hill. "Persistent citation of the only published randomized controlled trial of omega-3 supplementation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease six years after its retraction." Publications 3, no. 1 (2015): 17-26.

In this dataset 70 new and newly found citations are listed: 66 annotated citations and 4 pending citations (non-annotated since we don't have full-text).
"New citations" refer to articles published from March 25, 2014 to 2019, found in Google Scholar and Web of Science.
"Newly found citations" refer articles published 2006-2013, found in Google Scholar and Web of Science, but not previously covered in Ashley Fulton, Alison Coates, Marie Williams, Peter Howe, and Alison Hill. "Persistent citation of the only published randomised controlled trial of omega-3 supplementation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease six years after its retraction." Publications 3, no. 1 (2015): 17-26.

NOTES:
This is Unicode data. Some publication titles & quotes are in non-Latin characters and they may contain commas, quotation marks, etc.

FILES/FILE FORMATS
Same data in two formats:
2006-2019-new-citation-contexts-to-Matsuyama.csv - Unicode CSV (preservation format only)
2006-2019-new-citation-contexts-to-Matsuyama.xlsx - Excel workbook (preferred format)

ROW EXPLANATIONS
70 rows of data - one citing publication per row

COLUMN HEADER EXPLANATIONS
Note - processing notes

Annotation pending - Y or blank

Year Published - publication year

ID - ID corresponding to the network analysis. See Ye, Di; Schneider, Jodi (2019): Network of First and Second-generation citations to Matsuyama 2005 from Google
Scholar and Web of Science. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. <a href="https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2">https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-1403534_V2</a>

Title - item title (some have non-Latin characters, commas, etc.)

Official Translated Title - item title in English, as listed in the publication

Machine Translated Title - item title in English, translated by Google Scholar

Language - publication language

Type - publication type (e.g., bachelor's thesis, blog post, book chapter, clinical guidelines, Cochrane Review, consumer-oriented evidence summary, continuing education journal article, journal article, letter to the editor, magazine article, Master's thesis, patent, Ph.D. thesis, textbook chapter, training module)

Book title for book chapters - Only for a book chapter - the book title

University for theses - for bachelor's thesis, Master's thesis, Ph.D. thesis - the associated university

Pre/Post Retraction - "Pre" for 2006-2008 (means published before the October 2008 retraction notice or in the 2 months afterwards); "Post" for 2009-2019 (considered post-retraction for our analysis)

Identifier where relevant - ISBN, Patent ID, PMID (only for items we considered hard to find/identify, e.g. those without a DOI-based URL)

URL where available - URL, ideally a DOI-based URL

Reference number/style - reference

Only in bibliography - Y or blank

Acknowledged - If annotated, Y, Not relevant as retraction not published yet, or N (blank otherwise)

Positive / "Poor Research" (Negative) - P for positive, N for negative if annotated; blank otherwise

Human translated quotations - Y or blank; blank means Google scholar was used to translate quotations for Translated Quotation X

Specific/in passing (overall) - Specific if any of the 5 quotations are specific [aggregates Specific / In Passing (Quotation X)]

Quotation 1 - First quotation (or blank) (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 1 - English translation of "Quotation 1" (or blank)

Specific / In Passing (Quotation 1) - Specific if "Quotation 1" refers to methods or results of the Matsuyama paper (or blank)

What is referenced from Matsuyama (Quotation 1) - Methods; Results; or Methods and Results - blank if "Quotation 1" not specific, no associated quotation, or not yet annotated

Quotation 2 - Second quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 2 - English translation of "Quotation 2"

Specific / In Passing (Quotation 2) - Specific if "Quotation 2" refers to methods or results of the Matsuyama paper (or blank)

What is referenced from Matsuyama (Quotation 2) - Methods; Results; or Methods and Results - blank if "Quotation 2" not specific, no associated quotation, or not yet annotated

Quotation 3 - Third quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 3 - English translation of "Quotation 3"

Specific / In Passing (Quotation 3) - Specific if "Quotation 3" refers to methods or results of the Matsuyama paper (or blank)

What is referenced from Matsuyama (Quotation 3) - Methods; Results; or Methods and Results - blank if "Quotation 3" not specific, no associated quotation, or not yet annotated

Quotation 4 - Fourth quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 4 - English translation of "Quotation 4"

Specific / In Passing (Quotation 4) - Specific if "Quotation 4" refers to methods or results of the Matsuyama paper (or blank)

What is referenced from Matsuyama (Quotation 4) - Methods; Results; or Methods and Results - blank if "Quotation 4" not specific, no associated quotation, or not yet annotated

Quotation 5 - Fifth quotation (includes non-Latin characters in some cases)

Translated Quotation 5 - English translation of "Quotation 5"

Specific / In Passing (Quotation 5) - Specific if "Quotation 5" refers to methods or results of the Matsuyama paper (or blank)

What is referenced from Matsuyama (Quotation 5) - Methods; Results; or Methods and Results - blank if "Quotation 5" not specific, no associated quotation, or not yet annotated

Further Notes - additional notes
Date made availableFeb 23 2020
PublisherUniversity of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Keywords

  • citation context annotation, retraction, diffusion of retraction

Cite this

Ye, D. (Creator), Hill, A. (Creator), Whitehorn (Fulton), A. (Creator), Schneider, J. A. (Creator) (Feb 23 2020). Citation context annotation for new and newly found citations (2006-2019) to retracted paper Matsuyama 2005. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. 10.13012/B2IDB-8150563_V1